OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Sab Kuch Pehle se Likha Hai, To Protest Karna Fuzool Hai?
Ek objector ne sarcastic andaaz me kaha ke agar duniya me har cheez lohe mahfooz me likhi ja chuki hai, to phir Israel ke zulm ke khilaaf protest karna bekaar hai. Usne kaha ke agar Allah ne sab kuch pehle se taqdeer me likh diya hai, to woh Allah aur uske lohe mahfooz ke khilaaf hi protest karega.
SHORT ANSWER – Taqdeer likhne ka matlab yeh nahi ke zulm justified hai
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke lohe mahfooz me likhe hone ka matlab yeh nahi ke insan ka role khatam ho gaya. Har shakhs ka amal uske ikhtiyar se hota hai, aur Allah ne sirf record kiya hai, force nahi. Protest zulm ke khilaaf hona chahiye – lohe mahfooz ke khilaaf nahi.
DETAILED ANSWER – Lohe Mahfooz vs Human Responsibility
- Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke lohe mahfooz ek record system hai, koi remote control nahi.
- Allah ne insano ko free will di hai – har shakhs apne faislay khud karta hai, aur Allah usko likhta hai.
- Is base par agar Israel zulm karta hai, to uski zimmedari Israel par hi hai – lohe mahfooz sirf record hai.
- Objector ka kehna tha ke agar sab kuch likha hua hai, to protest ka kya faida? Jawab ye hai ke agar likhne se sab kuch justified ho jata, to qanoon, courts, aur insaaf ka bhi koi matlab nahi rehta.
- Sarcasm ke jawab me Mufti Yasir ne humor ka use karke samjhaya ke agar lohe mahfooz se itna gila hai, to protest bhi wahi jaake karo.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is sarcasm me chhupi logical galtiyan
Fallacy 1: Misunderstanding Divine Knowledge as Divine Control Lohe mahfooz Allah ka ilm hai, uska matlab yeh nahi ke insan ke actions us par majboor hain.
Fallacy 2: Equating Taqdeer with Endorsement Kisi cheez ka likha hona, uski tasdeeq ya pasand ka signal nahi hota.
Fallacy 3: Blaming the Record, Not the Actor Agar ek movie me villain ka act likha ho, to uska gila script se nahi hota, act se hota hai.
Fallacy 4: Ignoring Human Free Will Protest ya reaction ka matlab hota hai insani ikhtiyar aur jazbaat – aur wahi ikhtiyar ka proof hai.
Fallacy 5: Turning Philosophical Confusion into Mockery Taqdeer ke serious concept ko sarcastic banana na to objection ko strong banata hai, na valid.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Taqdeer ka matlab zimmedari se bhaagna nahi hota
Mufti Yasir ne ek zaruri baat yaad dilaayi: jo zulm karta hai, usi ko jawab dena hoga – Allah ke ilm me uska likha hua hona, us zulm ko legal ya moral nahi banata. Lohe mahfooz me likha hua har amal insan ki free choice ka nateeja hai. Agar koi haq ke khilaaf khada hota hai, to uska gila Allah se nahi – khud uss zulm karne wale se hona chahiye. Protest wahi meaningful hai jab target sahi ho.
