OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Mi’raj aur Mu’jizaat ko Science se Explain Karna Sahi Hai?
Ek objection yeh uthaya gaya ke agar Hazrat Isa (A.S.) 2000 saal pehle uthane gaye hain aur Quran ke mutabiq “1 din = 1000 saal” hai, to unko to sirf 2 din hue. Lekin Mi’raj ke waqia me Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke Rasool ﷺ ne kaafi waqt asmano me guzaara, lekin zameen pe waqt guzra hi nahi – bistar bhi garam tha. Yeh contradiction kaise solve ho? Kya yeh sab cheezen scientific logic se explain ki ja sakti hain?
SHORT ANSWER – Miracles ko science se prove karne ki koshish, unki asal nature ko distort karti hai
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke Mu’jiza wahi hota hai jo science aur natural laws ke daayre se bahar ho. Agar usse science se explain kar diya jaye, to wo mu’jiza nahi rehta – wo ek natural event ban jata hai. Miracles ka logic human dimensions se nahi, divine qudrat se chalta hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: Science ka scope limited hai, Allah ki qudrat nahi
Mufti Yasir ne kaha ke Miraj aur Isa A.S. ka uthaaya jaana, dono events supernatural hain. Quran ne sirf ek comparison diya ke “Allah ke haan ek din, tumhare 1000 saal ke barabar hai” – isse time ka nature samjha ja sakta hai, lekin exact equation nahi banayi ja sakti.
Unhone yeh bhi bataya ke space-time ek fabric hai, jisme Allah kisi ko kisi bhi point par le jaa sakta hai, aur wapas laa sakta hai usi moment me. Hazrat Aysha (R.A.) ka bistar garam hona ye batata hai ke Rasool ﷺ usi waqt wapas aaye jisme wo gaye the – kyunki Allah ka control space-time ke upar hai, na ke andar.
Science sirf natural cheezen samjha sakti hai, lekin miracles un se beyond hotay hain. Agar hum miracles ko science ke through explain karne ki aadat daal denge, to phir iman science pe ho jaayega – wahi sabse bada nuqsan hoga.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Miracles ko scientific banana ke 6 dangerous consequences
- Flaw 1: Category Mistake – Supernatural cheezon ko natural laws se measure karna logical error hai.
- Flaw 2: Faith Shift Risk – Science-based explanation se iman shift ho jaata hai divine source se scientific tools par.
- Flaw 3: Inconsistent Application – Har mu’jiza har situation me alag hota hai, usko ek standard se explain nahi kiya ja sakta.
- Flaw 4: Scientific Hijack – Jab sab kuch science ke hawale kar diya jaye, to wahi iman ban jaata hai.
- Flaw 5: Misinterpretation of Quran – 1 din = 1000 saal ka matlab “scale” hai, “duration” nahi.
- Flaw 6: Undermining Divine Will – Allah ki qudrat ko limited logic se bound karna khatarnaak fallacy hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Miracles science ke nahi, Allah ke hukum ke mutabiq hotay hain
Mufti Yasir ne bilkul clear kiya ke hume apne aqeede aur Imaan ko science ke neeche nahi rakhna chahiye. Jo Allah chahta hai, wo hota hai – aur uske liye time aur space sirf tools hain, limitations nahi. Mi’raj ya Hazrat Isa A.S. ka uthaaya jaana ek divine decision hai, jise human equations se samajhna nahi balki maanna chahiye. Science sirf ek auxiliary dalil ban sakti hai, lekin asal yaqeen wahi hai jo wahi ke zariye milta hai.
