Hindu Aur Islam Ki Wars Ka Maqsad – Objection Explained
Objection: Atheist/ex-Muslim/objector ne yeh point uthaya ke Hinduism ki jitni bhi badi ladai (specially Mahabharat), unka main motive zameen, rajgaddi ya political power tha. Mufti Yasir ne jawab me clarify kiya ke Islamic history me wars ka sabab kabhi land ya politics nahi tha, balke hamesha deen, iman, akhirat, ya Haq ke liye ladai hoti thi. Hindu history me motive physical possession tha, Islam me spiritual/moral cause.
Hinduism Aur Islam Ki Wars Ka Difference – Short Me Jawab
Mufti Yasir ka short jawab:
Hinduism ki badi wars jaise Mahabharat, sirf land, rajgaddi ya power ke liye thi. Islam me ladai ka maqsad kabhi zameen nahi tha, balke Haq, iman, aur akhirat par yaqeen tha. Nabi ﷺ ne khud kaha: “Agar mere ek haath me suraj, dusre me chand rakh do, main sachai se peeche nahi hatunga.” Land ya politics Islamic war ka focus nahi tha.
Kya Hinduism Ki Ladaiyan Sirf Land Ke Liye Hoti Thin? Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne detail me samjhaya:
Hindu history me wars, specially Mahabharat, ka core motive territory, rajgaddi ya land tha. Wahan power, property aur politics dominate karti thi. Islam me jab ladai hui to sirf ek wajah thi: Allah, Rasool, Quran, akhirat aur Haq par iman. Nabi ﷺ ne apni zindagi me yeh demonstrate kiya – agar dunya ki saari hukumat bhi mil jaye, Haq se peeche nahi hatna. Islamic ladai hamesha aqeede, morality, aur haqqaniyat ke liye hoti thi – land kabhi maqsad nahi bana.
Hinduism Wars Wale Objection Ki Logical Galtiyan – Flaws Explained
- Motives Ka Galat Comparison
Hindu wars (Mahabharat) ka main focus hamesha zameen aur power tha; Islam me yeh focus kabhi nahi tha. - Spirituality Ignore Karna
Islamic wars ka asal cause spiritual aur moral belief tha, na ke political ya land. - Prophet Ki Teachings Ko Overlook Karna
Nabi ﷺ ne hamesha Haq par rehne ki importance di, na ke land ya hukumat pane ki. - Quranic Perspective Bhool Jana
Mufti Yasir ne bataya – Quran me war ka goal Allah ka deen buland karna hai, na ke property capture karna. - History Ko Biased Tarike Se Compare Karna
Hindu wars ko sirf “dharma yuddh” keh kar asal motive (land/power) ko ignore karna galat hai.
Haq Ki Ladai Ya Land Ki Ladai – Final Thoughts
Islamic wars ka core maqsad kabhi zameen nahi raha. Nabi ﷺ ki zindagi aur unki statements clear hain – Haq par khade rehna sabse important hai, chahe kitna bhi political ya worldly pressure ho. Hinduism me ladai, specially Mahabharat, ka central motive land aur power tha. Islam aur Hindu wars ko compare karte waqt motives aur intentions ko samajhna zaruri hai. Haq ki ladai aur land ki ladai me farq hamesha clear raha hai.
