OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya University Jaane Se Madarsa Graduates Ka Aqeedah Kamzor Pad Jaata Hai?
Aksar log, khaaskar religious families aur traditional circles, yeh kehna shuru kar dete hain ke:
“Agar madarsa ka student university gaya to wo liberal ideas se mutasir ho jaayega.”
“Modern philosophy, feminism, ya atheism se uska imaan hil jaayega.”
Ye darr is wajah se hota hai kyunke secular institutions me liberal, materialist, aur Western thought dominate karti hai. Toh sawaal uthta hai — kya university jaana deen ke liye khatarnaak hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Madarsa Ka Student University Ja Sakta Hai Ya Nahi?
Bilkul ja sakta hai — lekin sirf tab jab uska apna deen, aqeedah, aur ilm-e-kalaam mazboot ho. Agar tayyari ke baghair gaya, to uska imaan compromise ho sakta hai. Lekin agar woh university me sirf secular theories ko analyze karne ja raha hai, seekhne nahi, to woh apna stand mazbooti se rakh sakta hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – MUFTI YASIR KA WAZEH JAWAB
Mufti Yasir ne teen core points highlight kiye:
1. Iman aur Ilm Mazboot Ho Toh Kahi Bhi Jaa Sakte Ho
Jab tak banda andar se mazboot nahi hoga, koi bhi external environment usko hila sakta hai. Is liye unhone kaha:
“Ghar se jab tak mazboot nahi honge, tab tak bahar mazboot nahi ho sakte.”
2. Ilm-e-Kalaam aur Falsafah Madarse Me Seekhna Zaruri Hai
Aksar scholars jo Western universities me jaake Islamic beliefs ko reconcile karne lagte hain (e.g. with evolution, feminism, liberalism) — unka apna ilm-e-kalaam kamzor hota hai.
“Unhone ilm-e-kalaam maghrib se seekha hota hai, Islam se nahi.”
3. Madarse Ko Hi Modern Thought Se Tayyar Karna Chahiye
Mufti Yasir ne recommend kiya ke madarsas me hi secular ideologies ka structured response sikhaya jaye — feminism, nationalism, scientism, etc. Taake students university jaake confused na ho, ready ho.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Universities Se Darne Walon Ki 5 Logical Galtiyan
1. Strawman Fallacy
Assume kar lena ke har university ka student atheism ya feminism ko accept kar lega — jabke kai log stronger ho kar bhi nikalte hain.
2. Fear-Based Reasoning
Deen ki mazbooti se zyada, sirf environment se darr lagna — Islamic tarbiyat par shaq karna hai.
3. Zero Preparation Assumption
Ye soch lena ke har madarsa student illogical ya untrained hota hai — jabke achhe madarse logic aur debate dono sikhate hain.
4. Overgeneralization
Kuch logon ke fitnah me padne ka matlab sab padhenge — ye logic nahi hota.
5. Isolationist Mentality
University se door bhaagne ka matlab Islam ko weak tasawwur karna — jabke Islam har platform par challenge face kar sakta hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Dawat Karni Hai Ya Sirf Darna Hai?
Agar Muslim students confident, prepared, aur intellectual banenge to woh har secular institute me Islam ka stance represent kar sakte hain. University se bhaagna solution nahi — tayyari ke saath jaana solution hai.
Mufti Yasir ka mission bhi yahi hai:
Madarse ko modern thought ke jawab ka markaz banao, taake dawat ke maidan me har jagah Islam represent ho.
