Kya Buddhism Duniya Ko Shanti De Sakta Hai? – Mufti Yasir Ka Jawab
OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Buddhism sach me ek peaceful solution hai?
Ek objector ne kaha ke unhone Buddhism is liye apnaya kyunki usme unko “inner peace” mila. Unka kehna tha ke duniya sirf dukh se bhari hui hai, aur Buddha ke meditation techniques se hi asli sukoon milta hai. Unhone claim kiya ke duniya ka har kaam result-oriented nahi hona chahiye, aur agar sab log sirf peace ke liye jeeyin to duniya behtar ho jayegi.
SHORT ANSWER – Kya Buddhism sach me sukoon deta hai?
Agar duniya sirf dukh ka naam hoti, to sukoon aur peace ka concept bhi na hota. Buddha ke meditation techniques temporary relief to de sakti hain, lekin jab zindagi ka ultimate goal hi contradiction ban jaye – jese ke ‘result chhodo, lekin result hi paana hai’ – to woh philosophy khud hi collapse ho jaati hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka logical jawab
Mufti Yasir ne sabse pehle yeh point uthaya ke agar duniya sirf dukh se bhari hoti, to hum sukoon ko pehchan bhi nahi paate. Dukh aur sukoon dono ek dosre ka scale hain. Sirf dukh ka hona logically impossible hai jab tak sukoon ka tasawwur na ho.
Phir unhone yeh challenge kiya ke agar sab log result-oriented kaam chhod dein, to duniya ka economic, social aur educational system collapse ho jayega. Har student, employee, aur inventor kisi na kisi goal ke liye kaam karta hai. Agar yeh goal chhod diya jaye to productivity khatam ho jaayegi.
Unhone Buddhist logic ko self-contradictory bataya: ek taraf kaha ja raha hai ke ‘result ka pichha mat karo’, aur doosri taraf ‘nirvana’ jaise result ko target banaya gaya hai. Jab ultimate goal hi diya gaya ho, to phir result se mukarrar hone ka kehna sirf illusion hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Buddhism ke 5 logical contradictions
- False Generalization – Duniya ko sirf dukh se bhara hua kehna har tarah ki khushi ko ignore karta hai.
- Contradiction Fallacy – Meditation ka goal peace hai, lekin peace ko result nahi kehna – yeh khud ek logical clash hai.
- Denial of Human Nature – Insan fitratan result-oriented hai; usse yeh quality chheen lena unnatural hai.
- Collapse Argument – Agar har shakhs result chhod de, to duniya ka system hi gir jaayega.
- Borrowed Concept Fallacy – ‘Religion’ ka concept borrow karke Buddhism ko ‘non-religion’ kehna ek philosophical theft hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Kya Buddhism ka peace sach ka sukoon hai?
Buddhism ek aise system ka wada karta hai jo dukh se nijat ka rasta dikhata hai – lekin jab usi system ke andar contradictions ho jayein, to wo peace sirf ek illusion ban kar reh jaata hai. Mufti Yasir ne yeh sabit kiya ke Islam sirf temporary peace nahi, balki long-term meaning aur purpose bhi deta hai. Shanti tabhi mumkin hai jab logic aur nature dono ka balance ho – aur yehi Islam ka promise hai.
