OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Islam me National Flag Lagana Haram Hai?
Kuch log, khas taur par overly religious circles ya ex-Muslim circles me, yeh objection uthate hain ke Independence Day manaya jaana, ya national flag lagana shirk ya Islam se ghaddari ke barabar hai. Unka kehna hai ke Islam sirf do Eidon ka mazhabi tasalsul maanta hai, baaqi sab innovation ya haram culture hai. Is objection par Mufti Yasir ne clear aur balanced jawab diya.
SHORT ANSWER – Watan se mohabbat jaiz hai, lekin blind nationalism nahi
Islam me apne watan se mohabbat karna mana nahi hai. National Day ya flag lagana ek cultural act hai – religious act nahi. Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke agar ye kaam kisi jazbe se, mohabbat se kiya jaye to jaiz hai. Har cheez ko shirk ka label dena ghalat hai. Lekin agar kisi par flag na lagane ki wajah se gaddari ka ilzam lagaya jaye, to ye hyper-nationalism hai, jo Islam ke khilaf hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: Mohabbat aur Mazhab ke darmiyan farq samajhna zaroori hai
Mufti Yasir ne explain kiya ke Independence Day jesa koi event, agar religious context me na ho aur sirf ek cultural ya national celebration ho, to Islam usko na haram kehta hai na wajib. Har mulk me azadi ka din manaya jata hai, aur azadi Allah ki badi ne’mat hai. Us ne’mat ko yaad karne ka din manane me koi harj nahi – jab tak usme shirk ya mazahbi ghuloo na ho.
Unhone yeh bhi clarify kiya ke agar koi flag nahi lagata, to us par gaddar hone ka label chipkana zulm hai. Nationalism jab hadd se barh jaye aur insaan ko religious ya insani farz se door kar de – to wo fitnah ban jata hai. Islam patriotism ki ijazat deta hai, lekin aise junoon ko reject karta hai jisme dusron ko zor zabardasti ki jaye.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Nationalism ko Islam se clash karwana ke 5 logical issues
- Flaw 1: False Dichotomy – National identity aur Islamic faith ko unnecessary opposition me rakhna.
- Flaw 2: Mislabeling – Har cultural act ko shirk ya bid’ah keh dena without evidence.
- Flaw 3: Coercion Justification – Dusron par flag na lagane par pressure dalna Islam ke khilaf hai.
- Flaw 4: Emotional Extremism – Mohabbat-e-watan ko blind ghuloo tak le jaana hyper-nationalism ban jata hai.
- Flaw 5: Ignoring Context – National symbols ka mazhabi misuse aur personal choice me farq na karna.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Islam insaaf ka deen hai, na ke jazbaati nationalism ka
Mufti Yasir ne ek balanced model diya – jahan Islam aapko apne watan se mohabbat karne ki ijazat deta hai, lekin blind nationalism jahan logic aur justice khatam ho jaye, usse mana karta hai. Jhanda lagana ya na lagana personal choice hai – aur kisi ki insani value is pe depend nahi karti. Islam hume har amal me niyyah, justice aur balance ka hukm deta hai – chahe wo deen ho ya culture.
