OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Sanatan sabse purana hai, to Islam ka kya maqam?
Ek objector ne kaha ke “Sanatan Dharma duniya ka sabse purana tareeqa-e-zindagi hai, aur Islam to 1400 saal pehle aaya. Agar Allah ne sabko banaya, to sabse pehle Islam kyun nahi bheja? Aur agar Allah waqai sabka hai, to sirf Qur’an aur Mohammad ﷺ par hi kyun complete focus hai?”
Sawal ye bhi tha ke:
- Pehle logon ko kufr kyun mila?
- Agar har prophet ne wahi paighaam diya, to Islam sabse aakhri kyun?
- Kya har culture, har tareeqa zindagi Allah ki taraf se hi hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Islam akhir me nahi, pehle se tha!
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya: Islam koi naya deen nahi, balke wahi pehla aur asli paighaam hai jo Adam (A.S) se lekar Muhammad ﷺ tak sabhi paighambaron ke zariye aaya. Har Prophet ne ek hi message diya: “Ek Allah ki ibadat karo.” Qur’an aakhri tanzil hai, Islam ka concept sabse purana hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Islam ki timeline aur Sanatan ka da’wa Mufti Yasir ki zubaani
Mufti Yasir ne is poore debate me kuch key baatein wazeh ki:
- Islam Prophet Muhammad ﷺ se start nahi hua. Pehle bhi Allah ne paighambar bheje – Adam, Nuh, Ibrahim, Musa, Isa (A.S) sabko wahi Allah ne bheja.
- “Muslim” ka matlab hota hai: “jo apni marzi ko Allah ke hukum ke aage jhuka de.” To har wo shaks jo Allah ko Creator maan kar uske hukum par chale, wo Muslim hai — chahe wo kisi bhi zamane ka ho.
- Sanatan ke da’we par, unhone challenge kiya: “Agar aapka tareeqa-e-zindagi Allah ki taraf se tha, to uska evidence, chain of transmission, ya unbroken scriptural record kya hai?”
- Islam ke paas Qur’an hai — jiska transmission documented hai, aur paigham beginning se consistent hai: Ek Allah, uski ibadat, aur akhlaqi zindagi.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Sanatan sabse purana hone ke da’we me kya logical galtiyan hain?
1. Appeal to Age Fallacy
Sirf kisi cheez ka “old” hona usay haq nahi banata. Purana matlab sahi hona zaruri nahi hota.
2. Lack of Evidence
Sanatan ke da’we ke liye koi documented unbroken chain ya scientific proof nahi diya gaya. Sirf “hamare buzurg kehte the” kafi nahi hai.
3. Mixing Culture with Religion
Culture (like cow worship or tree respect) ko religion ka hissah bana dena Allah ki taraf se aane wale wahi ka alternative nahi banata.
4. False Equivalence
“Har ek ko apne tareeke se rehne do” ka matlab ye nahi ke sab tareeqe Allah ke bheje hue hain.
5. Misunderstanding ‘Islam’
Objector Islam ko 1400 saal purana samajh raha tha, jabke Islam ek concept hai jo har prophet ke saath tha.
6. Confusing Creator with Tradition
Kisi cheese ka nature-friendly hona ya purana hona ye prove nahi karta ke wo Creator ka bheja hua system hai.
7. Selective Respect Argument
“Sabka samman” kehne ke bawajood, Islamic beliefs ko inferior ya late kehkar dismiss karna self-contradiction hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Purana hone se nahi, haqq hone se paighaam sach hota hai
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke Islam koi imported ya forced system nahi hai. Ye wahi fitri aur logical deen hai jo sabse pehle aaya tha — bas Qur’an uska aakhri aur final version hai. Sanatan ka da’wa tabhi valid hoga jab uske paas bhi wahi clarity, chain, aur divine sanction ho jo Islam ke paas documented form me hai. Otherwise, old doesn’t mean true.
Aakhirat ke liye Allah ka system hamesha se ek hi raha hai — aur us system ka naam hai Islam.
