OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Reincarnation aur Moksha Ka Concept Islam Se Behtar Hai?
Aik Hindu guest (Brijesh Rudrani) ne debate me yeh sawal uthaya ke Islam me insaan ke marne ke baad kya hota hai? Unhone Hindu dharm ka concept explain kiya: Swarg, Narak aur Moksha. Unka kehna tha ke agar koi achhe karm kare to use Moksha milta hai, jisme dobara janm nahi hota, aur agar bure karm kiye to Narak ya punarjanm hota hai – kabhi janwar ban kar, kabhi insaan ban kar. Unhone sawal uthaya: “Agar Islam me janm-maran ka cycle nahi hai, to itne log kaha se aa rahe hain? Roohon ka source kya hai?”
SHORT ANSWER – Reincarnation ka jawab: Islam me Soul ka clear aur logical system
Islam ke mutabiq har soul Allah ka creation hai, aur uska sirf ek hi duniya ka safar hota hai. Insaan marne ke baad dobara duniya me nahi aata. Uski final destination ya to Jannah hai ya Jahannam, based on his actions and beliefs. Islam me Moksha ya punarjanm ka concept nahi – balke clear judgement system hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: Na punarjanm, na Moksha. Sirf ek life, ek hisaab.
Mufti Yasir ne explain kiya ke Islam me salvation (Najaat) ka matlab hai ke insaan is duniya me apni life ko Allah ke hukum ke mutabiq guzare. Jis tarha Hinduism me Moksha milta hai sanyas aur duniya se alag ho kar, Islam isko reject karta hai. Islam ke mutabiq banda apne maa baap, biwi bachon, society ke darmiyan rehte hue bhi apni duty nibha kar Allah ki raza hasil kar sakta hai. Jis shakhs ka aqeeda sahi ho aur amal theek ho, uska hisaab Qayamat ke din hoga – aur agar wo pass hua to usay Jannat milegi, jahan se kabhi wapas nahi aayega.
Unhone ye bhi highlight kiya ke agar soul limited hoti aur reincarnation hota, to duniya ki population kabhi barh nahi sakti thi. Aaj agar population 10 billion cross kar chuki hai to iska matlab hai ke Allah naye souls create karta hai – wo Qadir hai har cheez par. Hindu belief ke mutabiq 10 arab souls hi hamesha se exist karti hain – to new log kaha se aa rahe hain?
OBJECTION FLAWS – Reincarnation aur Moksha wale theory me 6 logical flaws
- Flaw 1: Fixed Soul Fallacy – Agar souls limited hain to population kaise barh rahi hai?
- Flaw 2: Body-Based Salvation – Moksha me 16 saal ki body milti hai? To kya God ki bhi body 16 saal ki hai?
- Flaw 3: Contradictory Morality – Moksha ke liye maa baap ki service chhodo, lekin pyaar sirf Bhagwan se karo? Toh duty ka kya hua?
- Flaw 4: Omnipotence Contradiction – Agar Bhagwan new souls create nahi kar sakta, to wo all-powerful kaise hua?
- Flaw 5: Judgement Loop Problem – Punarjanm ka koi final hisaab nahi. Infinite loop me koi justice nahi hota.
- Flaw 6: Imitation of God – 16 saal ki body aur shape ka God limit create karta hai – jo uski divinity ko finite bana deta hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Salvation ka asli formula duniya me rehte hue amal se guzarta hai
Islam ek realistic aur practical system deta hai – na sanyas ki zarurat, na duniya chhodne ki. Najaat sirf Allah ke hukum ke mutabiq zindagi guzarne se milti hai. Is debate ne ye saabit kar diya ke Hindu moksha ka concept logical contradictions se bhara hua hai, jabke Islam ka model crystal clear hai: Ek life, ek death, ek judgement, ek final reward ya punishment.
Apni duniya ki duty nibhao, aur akhirat ki tayyari karo – yahi hai asli freedom.
