OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya idol worship God ka insult nahi hota?
Ek objector ne sawal uthaya ke Hindu log jab murti pooja karte hain, to kya sab log shirk kar rahe hote hain? Kuch log kehte hain ke murti asli mein khuda nahi hai, sirf uski form ya representation hai. Phir bhi kya ye shirk hai? Aur agar murti Allah ki creation se bani hai, to kya ye Allah ki tauheen kehna sahi hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Murti pooja symbolic ho ya literal, shirk hi rahega
Agar koi insan kisi bhi cheez me Allah ka zaat ya sifat samajhne lage — chahe us cheez ko khuda ka symbol hi kyu na kahe — to Islam ke mutabiq wo shirk karega. Aur shirk ka anjaam Quran ke mutabiq hamesha ke liye jahannum hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka logical jawab idol worship ke khilaf
Mufti Yasir ne idol worship ko shirk ki do categories me explain kiya:
- Shirk fi Zaat – Jab koi directly kisi cheez ko Allah ka alternate samajhta hai. Jaise do alag alag deities: ek khair ka malik, ek sharr ka malik.
- Shirk fi Sifaat – Jab kisi makhlooq me Allah ki qualities daal di jayein. Jaise kisi murti ko sajda karna, ye maan kar ke isme Allah ki sifaat hai.
Agar koi banda kehta hai ke murti Allah ka transformation hai, ya Allah ka reflection hai, to wo Shirk fi Sifaat kar raha hai. Murti ko Allah ka medium samajhkar ibadat karna shirk hai, chahe uska reason koi bhi ho.
Phir Mufti Yasir ne aik example diya:
Agar ek scientist ek intelligent robot banata hai jo kitchen me kaam karta hai — aur phir koi kehde ke yeh robot hi scientist hai — to kya yeh scientist ki tauheen nahi hogi?
Isi tarah Allah ki makhlooq ko khuda samajhna ya uski ibadat karna — ye direct Allah ki tauheen hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Idol Worship ke logical contradictions
- Fallacy of Symbolic Shirk – Agar koi object Allah nahi hai, to uski ibadat symbolic bhi haram hai.
- Creation ≠ Creator – Kisi bhi perfect cheez ka hona is baat ka daleel nahi ke wo khuda hai.
- Category Mistake – Creator aur creation ke beech clear boundary hai. Ye confuse karna khatarnaak hai.
- Emotional Appeal – Murti sundar hai, madad milti hai — ye logic nahi, sirf feeling hai.
- Tauheen of Creator – Jo cheez Allah ne banayi hai, usko hi Allah kehna usi ki tauheen hai.
- Universal Law in Islam – Shirk chahe kisi form me ho, Quran ke mutabiq mafi ka laayak nahi.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Allah ke maqam ko samajhna hi tawheed hai
Islam me sabse pehla aur sabse important rule hai: Allah ka koi shareek nahi. Agar koi insaan kisi bhi form me — chahe emotional ya symbolic — Allah ke sath kisi aur ko jodta hai, to wo shirk hai. Aur shirk sirf ek aqeeda nahi, ye Allah ki izzat aur maqam ko challenge karna hai. Jab tak Allah ko usi ke level par samjha nahi jata, insaan kabhi haqiqi tauheed ko nahi samajh sakta.
