OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Musalman har jagah suffer kyun kar rahe hain agar Allah unka hai?
Ek Sanatani objector ne sawal uthaya: agar Allah sabse zyada powerful hai, to phir Musalman duniya me har jagah takleef kyun jhel rahe hain? Har interview me, har war me, har situation me kya Muslims fail isliye ho rahe hain kyunki Allah madad nahi kar raha? Kya Islam sach hone ke bawajood koi faida nahi deta?
SHORT ANSWER – Madad dua se nahi, tayari se aati hai
Allah ki madad sirf Muslim identity pe nahi, action + preparation + tawakkul pe milti hai. Islam me duniya cause and effect ka system hai — agar Musalman tayyari nahi karein, to sirf iman unhe result nahi dega. Madad us waqt aati hai jab insaan poori mehnat karta hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: Musalman hone ka matlab shortcut nahi
Mufti Yasir ne objector ke sawal ka jawab seedhi logic se diya:
- Duniya ka system cause & effect pe chalta hai.
Chahe Muslim ho ya non-Muslim — agar koi qualified hai, to job usi ko milegi. - Quran ne tayyari ka hukm diya hai: “Wa-a’iddu lahum ma istata’tum min quwwatin”
“Tayyari karo jitna mumkin ho” (Surah Anfal: 60) - Hadith ka concept:
Ek sahabi ne kaha: “Main oont chhod ke aaya hoon, tawakkul karta hoon.”
Prophet ﷺ ne jawab diya: “Pehle oont baandho, phir tawakkul karo.” - Afghanistan ki misaal:
20 saal ke jadd-o-jehad ke baad superpowers ko haraya — kyunki tayyari bhi thi aur tawakkul bhi. Agar sirf dua hoti aur mehnat na hoti, to yeh result nahi aata. - Madad ka matlab:
Madad ka matlab yeh nahi ke har waqt Muslims hi jeetenge. Sometimes bura ghalib hota hai, lekin woh bhi system ka part hai. Allah har waqt direct interfere nahi karta, especially jab nabi zinda na ho.
OBJECTION FLAWS – “Allah madad nahi karta” wale logic ki 5 ghaltiyan
1. Instant Result Fallacy:
Objector expect karta hai ke har dua turant kaam kare — jabke dua ek long-term process hai.
2. Effortless Faith Assumption:
Muslim hone ka matlab ye nahi ke bina tayyari sab kuch mil jaye. Quran aur Hadith dono me action pe focus hai.
3. Over-Simplified Definition of Help:
Madad ka matlab ye nahi ke har jagah Muslims jeetein. Kabhi defeat bhi test hoti hai.
4. Misunderstanding Divine Plan:
Allah ka nizaam dunya me sabko barabar moka deta hai. Jo duniya ke rules follow karega, wo duniya me aage niklega — chahe wo Muslim ho ya na ho.
5. Confusion Between Duniya & Aakhirah:
Musalman akhirat ke liye struggle karta hai. Duniya me har waqt jeet zaroori nahi, lekin akhirat me jeet imaan aur amal se hoti hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Allah unfair nahi, lekin system-based hai
Allah ne duniya ek system ke tahat banayi hai – jisme reason, logic, aur struggle chalte hain. Sirf Muslim hone se help nahi milti. Help milti hai preparation + sabr + imaan ke sath. Jo Muslim is formula par chalega, wo duniya me bhi kamyab hoga aur akhirat me bhi. Jo shortcut chahta hai, wo Islam ko samjha hi nahi.
