OBJECTION EXPLAINED – “Kya Islam Insaniyat ke Naam Pe Nafrat Phailata Hai?”
Ek sanatani objector ne live call me yeh claim kiya ke Quran me likha hai: “Jahan kafir dikhe, maar do.” Usne yeh bhi kaha ke Muslims non-Muslims ke festivals me participate nahi karte, unhe hate karte hain, aur is wajah se Islam insaniyat ka deen nahi ho sakta.
SHORT ANSWER – “Islam Kafir Ko Maarne Ka Hukm Deta Hai?” ka short jawab
Nahi. Quran ka “kafir ko maarne” wala hukm sirf battlefield ke context me hai — randomly road par chal rahe non-Muslim ko maarne ka koi order Islam me nahi. Har aayat ka maqsad, time aur condition hoti hai, jo uske baghair samajhna galat conclusion deta hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ne kaise jawab diya?
Mufti Yasir ne pehle yeh clarify kiya ke:
- Quran me koi bhi aisi general instruction nahi hai jo Muslims ko har non-Muslim ko maarne ka hukm de.
- Jang ke ayat sirf specific war situations me nazil hui thi — jese kisi enemy army ke khilaf.
- Mufti Yasir ne Hindu texts ka bhi reference diya (Manusmriti aur Skand Puran) jisme likha hai ke jo dharm-virodhi ho, usse desh se nikal do ya usay jala do.
- Islam me kafir ka matlab hai “truth rejecter” — lekin is naam se kisi ke sath zulm nahi kiya jata.
- Islam me war ka concept zulm khatam karne ke liye hai, na ke religion pe zabardasti thopne ke liye.
OBJECTION FLAWS – “Islam Kafir ke sath Discriminate karta hai” me 5 Logical Ghaltiyan
1. Context Chhupana:
Objector ne battlefield context ko ignore kiya, jahan ayat actually apply hoti hai.
2. Double Standards:
Jab Hindu texts me bhi kafir ya nindak ke khilaf sakht hukum hain, to sirf Islam ko target karna biased hai.
3. Misquotation of Quran:
Quran ki ayat ko aadhe hisse me quote karke poore message ka matlab change kar diya gaya.
4. Generalization Fallacy:
Ek do ayaton ka war-time hukm sab non-Muslims par aam kar diya gaya — jabke Quran me aisa nahi hai.
5. Ignoring Quranic Ethics:
Quran me bar bar aman, insaaf aur padosiyon ke huqooq ka zikr hai — unhe ignore karna dishonest hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – “Islam Insaniyat Ka Dushman Hai?” ka Emotional Logic
Agar Islam sirf nafrat ka paigham deta to 1400 saal me sabse zyada log isay kabool na karte. Quran jahan jang ka zikr karta hai, wahan zulm ke khilaf stand lene ki baat karta hai — aur yeh har sachay insaan ka kaam hona chahiye. Jo log ayaton ko tod-mod ke present karte hain, unka maqsad samajhdaari nahi, propaganda hota hai.
