Objection Explained – Do Khuda Kyun Nahi Ho Sakte? Logic Samjho
Objection ye tha ke agar duniya me kai log ek company ya ek system ko milkar chala sakte hain, to kya 2 ya zyada khuda nahi ho sakte? Ek Hindu objector ne poocha ke agar dono khuda all-powerful hain, aur sab kuch perfectly kar sakte hain, to unka hona contradiction kyun ban jata hai? Agar dono ka opinion same ho to problem kya hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Do Khuda Kyun Nahi Ho Sakte? Simple Jawab
Agar do khuda hon aur unka opinion kabhi alag ho jaye, to dono me se ek galat hoga — aur jo galat ho wo khuda nahi ho sakta. Agar dono ka opinion hamesha same ho, to fir wo dono alag nahi hue — fir wo do nahi, ek hi hain. Logical conclusion: khuda sirf ek hi ho sakta hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir Ka Logical Breakdown
Mufti Yasir ne step-by-step bataya ke agar 2 khuda hon:
- To ya to dono ke opinions hamesha same honge → fir unme koi difference nahi → fir wo 2 nahi, 1 hi hue.
- Agar opinions kabhi different honge → to ek sahi hoga, dusra galat → galti karne wala khuda nahi ho sakta.
- Aur agar dono independent ho kar bhi opposite opinion dene ki capability nahi rakhte → to wo incapable hain → incapable bhi khuda nahi ho sakta.
Fir unhone ye bhi samjhaya ke:
- Do perfectly powerful aur infinite beings agar hon bhi, to unme koi farq hona chahiye tabhi wo “do” kehlayenge.
- Aur agar farq hai — jaise jagah, waqt, ya authority mein — to fir unka all-powerful hona khatam ho gaya.
- Jab ek khuda har kaam khud se kar sakta hai, to dusre ki zarurat hi nahi.
To jo cheez logically possible hi nahi, wo exist nahi kar sakti.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Do Khuda Theory Ke Logical Errors
1. Identity Fallacy:
Agar dono khuda bilkul same hain to fir wo “do” kaise hue? Do cheezain tabhi alag hoti hain jab unme koi farq ho.
2. Contradiction in Capability:
Agar dono opposite opinion de sakte hain → contradiction hoga → ek wrong hoga → wrong waala khuda nahi.
3. Incapability Paradox:
Agar dono kabhi opposite opinion nahi de sakte → iska matlab wo kar nahi sakte → limitation → limitation waala khuda nahi ho sakta.
4. Redundant Entity Fallacy:
Jab ek khuda sab kuch akela perfectly kar sakta hai → to dusre ki presence redundant hai → aur khuda koi extra cheez nahi hota.
5. Space Occupation Problem:
Agar do khuda alag-alag jagah ho (left/right, above/below) → to wo space-bound ho gaye → aur khuda space-bound nahi ho sakta.
6. Ownership Division Problem:
Agar 50% ek khuda ke paas ho aur 50% dusre ke → to dono limited hue → aur limited koi bhi khuda nahi ho sakta.
7. Eternal Creation Fallacy:
Agar ek khuda ne dusre ko banaya → to dusra eternal nahi raha → aur jo eternal nahi, wo khuda nahi.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Sirf Ek Hi Khuda Kyun Hona Chahiye?
Ek khuda ka hona sirf aqeedah nahi, logic ka demand hai. Do ya zyada khuda hone ka matlab hota hai conflict, dependency ya limitation – aur in teeno me se koi bhi khuda ke concept me fit nahi hota. Agar ek khuda har kaam bina kisi madad ke kar sakta hai, to dusre khuda ki zarurat banana sirf insani soch ka limitation hai — khuda ke perfection ka nahi.
