KYA Islam Me “Terror” Jaiz Hai Ya Galat Fehmi Hai?

OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Muhammad ﷺ ne Islam ko “terror” ke zariye phailaya?

Satendra Singh ne objection uthaya ke Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ne Islam ko “terror” ya “dahshat” ke zariye phailaya. Unhone ek Hadith ka reference diya (Sahih Muslim 108) jisme aata hai ke “mujhe ro’b ke zariye madad di gayi.” Unka kehna tha ke agar Prophet ﷺ khud ye keh rahe hain ke unko ‘terror’ diya gaya, to iska matlab Islam khauf ke zariye phaila — na ke dawat aur akhlaaq ke zariye.

SHORT ANSWER – Islam terror se nahi, dawat aur logic se phaila; ro’b sirf law and order ke liye tha

Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ne kabhi nahi kaha ke Islam ko terror ke zariye phailaya gaya. Hadith ka matlab hai ke unki state authority itni strong thi ke unka naam sunkar dusman jhuk jaate the — bina jang ke aman ho jata tha. Ye ro’b “dahshatgardi” nahi, deterrence tha — jaise har modern state ka law and order maintain karne ke liye hota hai.

DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: “Terror” aur “state authority” me farq hai

Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya:

1. Hadith ka lafz “ro’b” hai, not ‘terror’ – Ye lafz “psychological deterrence” ke liye aata hai, jise Prophet ﷺ ki presence se criminals dar jaate the.
2. Islam dawat se phaila, na ke force se – Prophet ﷺ ne khud farmaya: “Bashiru wala tunaffiru” – logon ko khushkhabri do, nafrat mat paida karo.
3. Law enforcement ke liye ro’b zaroori hai – Jaise aaj ke commissioner ka naam sunke chor chup jaayein, waise hi Prophet ﷺ ka naam dusmanon ke liye ro’b tha.

Mufti Yasir ne ye bhi bataya ke objection ne Islam ki political strategy ko terrorist ideology samajh liya — jabke ye sirf state-level deterrence tha, na ke civilian terror.

OBJECTION FLAWS – Is objection me 6 major logical ghalatiyan

1. Mistranslation Fallacy:
   “Ro’b” ka matlab “terrorism” nahi hota. Ro’b = deterrence, psychological impact. Ye deliberate mistranslation thi.
2. Equating State Law with Terror:
   Har state police aur army se ro’b banata hai. Iska matlab ye nahi ke wo terrorist hai.
3. Ignoring Dawah History:
   Islam 23 saal me dawat aur sabr se phaila. Force sirf extreme self-defense me use hua.
4. False Comparison with Modern Terrorism:
   Prophet ﷺ ka ro’b criminals aur betrayers ke liye tha. Innocent civilians ke liye nahi.
5. Mixing Religion and Politics:
   Prophet ﷺ ek Nabi bhi the aur ek head of state bhi. Unki hukumat ka discipline maintain karna unka farz tha.
6. Cherry Picking Hadith:
   Ek hadith se conclusion nikaalna bina context samjhe, misleading hota hai. Puri Seerat is baat ka proof hai ke Islam peace aur insaaf ka deen hai.

FINAL THOUGHTS – Ro’b justice ke liye ho, to woh rehmat hota hai, zulm nahi

Islam ka pegham peace, logic aur equality hai. Lekin jab society me injustice ho, to us injustice ko rokne ke liye ro’b zaroori hota hai. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ka ro’b criminals ke liye tha — taake wo zulm se ruk jaayein. Ye wahi strategy hai jo har aqilmand state aaj bhi apnaati hai. Islam ne kabhi civilians ko terrorize nahi kiya — usne hamesha justice establish kiya.