OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Earth ka size universe ke muqablay me kuch bhi nahi, to Allah ne is par itni tawajju kyun di?
Ye objection atheist ne ye soch kar uthaya ke poora universe itna bara hai, lekin Earth usme sirf ek “dust particle” jaisa hai. To phir Allah ne yahi chhoti si duniya kyun chuni, aur yahan pe kyun hazaron paighambar bheje? Kya Allah is chhoti si jagah ke liye “curious” hai? Yani, unka kehna hai ke size chhota hai to importance bhi chhoti honi chahiye.
SHORT ANSWER – Allah curious nahi hota, wo sab jaanta hai. Zameen ki ahmiyat usne khud tay ki hai
Curious hone ka matlab hota hai kisi unknown cheez ko jaanna chahna. Lekin Allah har cheez ka ilm rakhta hai, isliye ye lafz hi inappropriate hai. Earth ka size chhota ho sakta hai, lekin ahmiyat size se nahi — maqam se hoti hai. Allah ne is duniya ko imtihaan aur hidayat ka markaz banaya, isliye yeh zameen uski rehmat ka centre hai, chaahe wo chhoti hi kyun na ho.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: “Ahmiyat ka ta’alluq size se nahi, qeemat se hota hai”
Mufti Yasir ne ye point highlight kiya ke objection me do concepts ko mix kiya gaya hai:
size aur importance.
- Size chhota hai: Ye sach hai ke Earth ka size poori galaxy ya universe ke muqablay me na ke barabar hai.
- Ahmiyat zyada hai: Lekin kisi cheez ki importance uske size se nahi hoti. Allah ne Earth ko imtihaan ka maidan banaya, aur insan ko apni khilafat di — is wajah se ye duniya Allah ke nazdeek qeemati hai.
Mufti Yasir ne kaha:
“Agar koi aaka apne ghulaam ko importance de, to ghulaam usse pooch nahi sakta ke aap mujhe importance kyun de rahe hain.”
Yani hum Allah se poochne ki position me hi nahi hain ke “kyun” — kyunke woh khaliq hai, hum makhluq hain.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is objection me 6 basic ghaltiyan
- Wrong Word Usage (Curiosity):
Allah ke liye “curious” jaisa lafz use karna ghalat hai, kyunke curiosity ignorance pe based hoti hai. Allah sab kuch jaanta hai. - False Assumption: Size = Value:
Ye samajhna ke jo cheez badi hai woh hi valuable hai — logical fallacy hai. Diamond chhota hota hai, lekin pathar se zyada keemati hota hai. - Category Mistake:
Physical size ko spiritual importance ke saath mix karna galat hai. Duniya ka maqsad material nahi, moral testing hai. - Anthropocentric Projection:
Allah ke actions ko human logic me samajhne ki koshish karna — jaise Allah bhi hamari tarah prioritize karta ho. - Inversion of Authority:
Hum Allah ke decision ko judge nahi kar sakte. Ahmiyat ka tayun khaliq karta hai, creation nahi. - Selective Skepticism:
Atheist sirf wahi questions uthata hai jo emotional dikhte hain, lekin unke peeche solid reasoning nahi hoti.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Zameen chhoti ho sakti hai, lekin Allah ki nazar me qeemat uske maqsad se hoti hai
Yeh duniya chhoti zaroor hai, lekin uska mission bohot bara hai — yahi jagah insaan ke test ka maidan hai. Allah har cheez ka ilm rakhta hai, aur har cheez ko uski hikmat ke mutabiq plan karta hai. Jab Allah kisi chhoti cheez ko ahmiyat de, to yeh us cheez ki asli qeemat ka proof hai — na ke Allah ki “curiosity” ka. Aqal badi hoti hai, size nahi.
