Objection Explained – Kya Aaj Ke Zamane Me Khilafat Possible Hai?
Ex-Muslim aur secular critics ka ek common objection hai ke Islam sirf personal worship ka deen hona chahiye — politics aur state affairs me involve nahi hona chahiye. Unka kehna hai ke Islamic system (Khilafat ya Shariah-based governance) outdated ho chuka hai, aur agar koi isay implement karne ki baat karta hai to woh dictatorship ya theocracy impose karna chahta hai. Kuch log kehte hain ke Islam sirf masjid tak rehna chahiye, sarkar tak nahi.
Short Answer – Ji Haan, Jahan Muslim Majority Ho, Wahan Islamic System Farz Hai
Mufti Yasir Nadeem Al Wajidi kehte hain ke Islam ka nizaam sirf ibadat tak limited nahi hai — balke society aur governance tak jata hai. Jahan Muslims majority me hain (jaise Pakistan, Egypt, Indonesia etc.), wahan un par farz hai ke Islam ko social aur legal system ki soorat me qaim karein. Yeh baat fiqh aur aqeedah dono ke mutabiq hai.
Detailed Answer – Kya Islamic Rule Sirf Ek Dream Hai?
Mufti Yasir ne kuch core points clear kiye:
- Islami Nizaam Ko Qaim Karna Farz Hai
Yeh hukm sirf individuals ke liye nahi, balke governments, scholars aur Muslim majority communities ke liye bhi hai. Yeh farz hai ke wo secularism ya dictatorship ka jhuta support na dein. - Leadership Ka Tareeqa Flexible Hai
Khilafat ka tariqa mutaghayyir ho sakta hai. Prophet ke baad 4 Khulafa ka selection alag tareeqon se hua — H. Abu Bakr via ijma, H. Umar via nomination, H. Usman via shura, H. Ali via people’s bay’ah. Toh model fixed nahi, lekin maqsood (goal) clear hai: Islami governance. - Non-Muslims Ke Rights Guaranteed Hai
Objection yeh bhi aata hai ke agar Islamic rule aaya to minorities ke rights khatam ho jaenge. Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke Islam ne non-Muslims ke ibadat khanon, khane peene, aur personal law ke rights ko historically preserve kiya hai. 1300 saal ka amal already exist karta hai as a blueprint. - Islamic Rule Sirf Zor Se Nahi Aata
Jang se nizaam nahi qaim hota. Public will, awareness, ulama ka united effort aur Muslim societies ka collective demand hi system change la sakta hai. Aur jab 90-95% Muslims ek country me hain, to voting aur awareness se nizaam aasani se implement ho sakta hai.
Logical Flaws in Objection
- “Religion Sirf Personal Hai” Fallacy
Islam purely personal nahi — economic, social, legal, sab cover karta hai. Sirf spiritualism Islam ka half truth hai. - “Secularism Is Neutral” Illusion
Secularism khud ek ideology hai — Islam ko sidelining karke, liberalism ko law ka base bana deta hai. Yeh neutral nahi hota. - “Islamic Rule Means Oppression” Myth
Historical Islamic rule ne minorities ko zyada protection diya as compared to modern secular models (jaise France me hijab ban, India me mob lynching). - “Leadership Model Fix Hona Chahiye” Assumption
Objection assume karta hai ke khilafat ka sirf ek tareeqa hona chahiye. Jabke Islam ne maqsood ko farz banaya hai, tareeqa ijtihaadi hai.
Final Thoughts – Farz Bhool Kar Islam Adhoora Rehta Hai
Mufti Yasir ne conclude kiya ke Islami Nizaam ko qaim karna sirf ek dream nahi — ek legal aur aqeedi farz hai. Sirf namaz, roza aur hajj se Islam mukammal nahi hota. Jab tak governance aur adal ka nizaam Islam se nahi aata, society zulm aur fasaad ka nizaam ban jaegi. Aaj bhi, agar 57 Muslim countries chaahein, to mil kar ek United Islamic Platform bana sakti hain — bina kisi bloodshed ke.