Kya Muslims Atheist Sirf Doubt Ki Wajah Se Ban’te Hain?
Objection Explained
Ek caller ne Mufti Yasir se poocha ke aaj kal kai Muslims Islam se door jaa rahe hain, ya atheist ban rahe hain — iska kya reason hai? Usne suggest kiya ke logon ka trust ulema aur Islamic representation se uth raha hai. Is par Mufti Yasir ne poori clarity ke saath samjhaya ke log atheism ki taraf kyun jaate hain — sirf intellectual doubt se nahi, balki emotional trauma aur nafs-parasti se bhi.
Muslims Atheist Kyun Ban’te Hain?
Short Answer
Muslims aksar do wajah se atheist bante hain: (1) koi emotional ya psychological trauma jise wo problem of evil ke through process nahi kar pate, (2) ya phir wo nafs-parasti (desire-based freedom) ke liye religion ko chhod dete hain. Sirf ulema ke character ya doubt ki wajah se nahi — deeper reasons bhi hotay hain.
Muslims Atheist Kyun Ban’te Hain?
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne teen bade reasons explain kiye:
- Problem of Evil + Trauma: Zindagi ke kisi painful incident (jaise kisi apne ki maut, illness, injustice) ne unko Allah ki existence pe doubt karwa diya. Wo sawal poochte hain: Agar Allah hai, to yeh kyun hua? Jab jawab nahi milta, to wo kufr ki taraf chalay jaate hain.
- Liberal Education System: Pakistan aur Muslim societies ke elite schools (jaise Beaconhouse) me secular mindset promote hota hai. Wahan se nikalne wale bachon ke minds Allah se door hote hain. Yeh system aise design hua hai ke wo deeni soch se incompatible ho.
- Nafs-parasti (Desire for Freedom): Kuch log deen ko isliye chhodte hain kyunki wo haram cheezen (sharab, zina, etc.) freely karna chahte hain. Unko Islam ki boundaries suit nahi karti, isliye wo Allah ka inkaar kar ke guilt-free life chahte hain.
Mufti Yasir ne ek hadith bhi indirectly reference ki: “Shubhah (doubt) agar haq ki taraf modha jaaye to hidayat milti hai, lekin agar us doubt ko weapon bana diya jaaye, to uska jawab debate se diya jaata hai.”
Muslims Atheist Kyun Ban’te Hain?
Objection Flaws
- Sirf Ulema Ko Blame Karna: Sab Muslims ke imaan ki zimmedari ulema par nahi hoti — har shakhs khud jawabdeh hai.
- Trauma ≠ Truth: Emotional pain genuine ho sakta hai, lekin usse conclude kar lena ke Allah nahi hai — logical fallacy hai.
- Selective Conversion Narrative: Atheism ka propaganda strong hai, lekin duniya me Islam sabse tez grow karne wala deen hai — jiska proof official reports me bhi milta hai.
- Secular Curriculum Trap: Secular schools logical thinking ke naam par Allah se door karte hain, lekin unki soch bhi incomplete aur biased hoti hai.
- Desires Ko Justify Karna: Haram ka irada rakh kar religion ko false kehna — yeh sincere doubt nahi, nafs ka issue hai.
- Activist Atheism = Dawa vs Debate: Jinko confusion hai unse naram ravayya hona chahiye, lekin jo log social media pe Islam ko attack karte hain, unka jawab dalail se diya jayega.
- Data Misinformation: Ex-Muslim trend dikhaya jata hai jaise Islam se log bhag rahe hain, jabke ground reality me log Islam me aa rahe hain (13 lakh log convert hue in recent data).
Muslims Atheist Kyun Ban’te Hain?
Final Thoughts
Har shakhs ke dil me koi na koi jazba hota hai — ya to usne Allah se sawaal kiya aur jawab na mila, ya wo Allah ke hukm se bachna chahta hai. Lekin Islam sach hai — chahe duniya isse chhod rahi ho ya accept kar rahi ho. Mufti Yasir ka paighaam clear hai: jo doubt se guzra ho, usse mohabbat se milo; lekin jo Islam ko todne aaya ho, usse dalail se muqabla karo.
