Kya Islamic State Me Freedom of Religion Nahi Hoti?
Objection Explained
Ek objector ne Mufti Yasir se sawaal kiya ke agar secular countries sab religions ko preach karne ki freedom deti hain, to Islamic states me dusre religions ko preach karne ki permission kyun nahi hoti? Kya yeh freedom of religion aur freedom of speech ke khilaaf nahi hai?
Kya Islamic State Me Freedom of Religion Nahi Hoti? Ka Short Me Jawab
Short Answer
Islamic state me basic religious practice allowed hoti hai — lekin state ideology ke khilaf preaching allowed nahi hoti, jaise kisi secular state me khilafat preach karna mana hai. Har system apne constitution ki hifazat karta hai. Islamic system bhi wahi karta hai.
Kya Islamic State Me Freedom of Religion Nahi Hoti? Ka Detailed Jawab
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke secular states apne aap ko neutral kehte hain, lekin unka constitution bhi kisi alternate system ko tolerate nahi karta.
Example:
- India ek secular democracy hai, lekin wahan Islamic khilafat ya Shariah system openly preach nahi kiya ja sakta — kyunki wo state ideology ko contradict karta hai.
- Isi tarah, ek Islamic state ka constitution Islam par based hota hai. Agar koi aake usi ke opposite ideology (jaise atheism ya idol worship) openly preach kare, to wo constitution ke khilaaf hota hai.
Mufti Yasir ne yeh bhi explain kiya:
- Secular states ne religions ko water-down kar diya hai — unke liye religion bas meditation aur personal belief ban gaya hai.
- Islamic state me religion public aur legal matter bhi hota hai. Is wajah se contradiction allowed nahi hota.
Unhone yeh bhi clarify kiya ke agar non-Muslim koi Islamic country me peacefully rahe, tax laws follow kare, aur state ke khilaf na ho, to unhe rehne aur ibadat ka haq milta hai.
Kya Islamic State Me Freedom of Religion Nahi Hoti? Ka Objection Me Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Constitutional Contradiction Ignore Karna
Har state apne basic framework ke khilaf ideology ko ban karti hai — Islamic ya secular dono systems me. - Secularism Ko Neutral Samajhna
Secularism neutral nahi — ek ideology hai jo religion ko private rakhna chahti hai, aur khud dominant role leti hai. - Religious Freedom vs. Political Challenge Mix Karna
Islamic state me religious worship allowed hoti hai, lekin state challenge karne wali ideology nahi. - Double Standards on Preaching
Secular countries jahan khilafat ya Shariah system preach karna ban hai, wahan log Islamic states se poori ideological freedom expect karte hain. - Misunderstanding of Political Identity
Buddhism jese religions ke paas political system nahi hota, isliye unhe compare karna Islamic state se flawed hai.
Kya Islamic State Me Freedom of Religion Nahi Hoti? Ka Final Jawab
Final Thoughts
Islamic state kisi ko basic religious worship se nahi rokti — lekin apne foundation ko challenge karne wali ideology ko support nahi karti, jaise secular states bhi apne framework ki hifazat karti hain. Freedom ka matlab anarchy nahi hota. Har system apni values protect karta hai. Islam is not against peace — it’s against those ideologies jo system ko undermine karen.
