Kya Secularism Sach Me Sabse Behtar Nizaam Hai?
Objection Explained
Aajkal kai log secularism ko ideal system samajhte hain — jahan sabko apne religion par chalne ki freedom milti hai. Lekin jab Mufti Yasir se poocha gaya ke secularism ka concept Islam se behtar hai ya nahi, to unhone clear kiya ke secularism sirf neutrality ka naam nahi, balki ek ideology hai jo religion ko public life se nikal kar corner me dhakelna chahti hai.
Kya Secularism Sach Me Sabse Behtar Nizaam Hai? Ka Short Me Jawab
Short Answer
Secularism ka matlab sirf religion se azaadi nahi, balki religion se hukumat ki azaadi hai. Is system me morality ka source corrupt politicians ban jaate hain, na ke wahi Ilahi hukum. Mufti Yasir ke mutabiq secularism ka facade neutral hai, lekin asal me yeh ek la-mazhabi dictatorship hai.
Kya Secularism Sach Me Sabse Behtar Nizaam Hai? Ka Detailed Jawab
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke secularism ek waqt tak ek vague idea tha — lekin ab secular states ke actions ne uski asal soorat expose kar di hai. Unka kehna tha:
- Secularism ≠ Religious Freedom
Secularism ka matlab yeh nahi ke sab religions ko barabari milegi. Balki secular system religion ko subordinate karta hai. - Secular System Decides Right/Wrong
Jab law banane ka haq Allah ke bajaye secular parliament ko mile, to morality ka scale personal bias ban jaata hai. - Secularism is the New Extremism
Mufti Yasir ne bold claim kiya ke modern secularist log religious logon se zyada extreme aur intolerant ho gaye hain. - Historical Proofs
India jese “secular” desh me minorities par zulm, aur North Korea jese atheistic state me dictatorship — ye sab secularism ke flaws hain.
Kya Secularism Sach Me Sabse Behtar Nizaam Hai? Ka Objection Me Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Neutrality Ka Dhoka
Secularism ka claim hai neutrality ka — lekin real-life me wo sirf religion-suppressing system ban jaata hai. - Morality Without Source
Secular law-making me koi final divine source nahi hoti — sirf flawed human opinions hote hain. - Minority Oppression in Secular States
India, France, aur North Korea jese secular states ne religion ke naam par nahi — balki secularism ke naam par oppression kiya. - Secularism as Hidden Religion
Secularism khud ek ideology hai — jo apne aap ko neutral kahkar apni beliefs impose karti hai. - Public Religion Suppression
Secular states sirf “personal” religion ki ijazat dete hain — public religious expression ban hoti hai.
Kya Secularism Sach Me Sabse Behtar Nizaam Hai? Ka Final Jawab
Final Thoughts
Secularism ka naara shayad appealing lagta ho, lekin asal me ye system Allah ke hukum ko irrelevant bana deta hai. Jab morality ka scale insani opinion ban jaye, to society chaos aur injustice ka shikar hoti hai. Islam ka hukumat ka model sirf justice nahi — spiritual accountability bhi lata hai. Jo log truly fair system chahte hain, unhe secularism nahi, wahi Ilahi hukum chahiye.
