Kya Menstruation Wali Hadith Ghalat Hygiene Sikhati Hai?

Kya Menstruation Wali Hadith Ghalat Hygiene Sikhati Hai?

Objection Explained
Ek objector ne Sahih Bukhari Hadith 312 par objection uthaya jahan Hazrat Aisha (RA) menstruation ke dino me sirf ek kapda istemal karne ka zikr karti hain. Objector ka kehna tha ke ye Islamic hygiene standards ko ganda aur immoral dikhata hai. Lekin jab usi tarah ka content Hindu scriptures se saamne laya gaya, to wo jawab dene se katra gaya.

Kya Menstruation Wali Hadith Ghalat Hygiene Sikhati Hai? Ka Short Me Jawab

Short Answer
Ye Hadith kisi ghaflat ya gande amal ko promote nahi karti — balki extreme poverty aur limited resources ke bawajood Islamic cleanliness ka ek example hai. Isme hygiene compromise nahi hua, balke us zamane ki mushkilat ke bawajood safai ki koshish dikhai gayi hai.

Kya Menstruation Wali Hadith Ghalat Hygiene Sikhati Hai? Ka Detailed Jawab

Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne wazahat ki ke Hadith 312 me Hazrat Aisha (RA) sirf ek kapde ka zikr karti hain jo unka personal garment tha — jo khas menstruation ke dino me use hota tha. Us zamane me resources bohot limited thay. Aksar log ek ya do hi kapdon me zindagi guzar dete thay.

Hadith me likha hai ke agar blood spot lag jata, to wo saliva se usse scrub kar leti thi. Iska matlab ye nahi ke Islam safai se door hai, balki un dino me available resources se bhi best possible hygiene maintain ki ja rahi thi. Aaj bhi agar pani na ho, to Islam dry cleaning (tayammum) jese solutions deta hai.

Mufti Yasir ne Hindu scriptures (Rigveda) me likhi menstruation-related lines ka bhi hawala diya — jahan aurat ko impurity ka source bataya gaya. Jab objector se pucha gaya ke kya un lines ko moral kahoge, to wo jawab dene se katra gaya.

Kya Menstruation Wali Hadith Ghalat Hygiene Sikhati Hai? Ka Objection Me Flaws

Objection Flaws

1. Context Ignore Karna
   Hadith me hygiene ke zamane aur limited means ko ignore kiya gaya. Yeh poor community ka masla tha, na ke lack of hygiene ka.
2. Partial Reading of Hadith
   Objector ne sirf ek jumla uthaya, lekin poori hadith ko nahi samjha jisme safai aur kapre ka maqsad wazeh hai.
3. Cultural Double Standard
   Islamic tradition ko ganda kehna, lekin khud ke dharmik texts me menstruation ko impurity bolna — hypocrisy hai.
4. False Equivalence with Modern Standards
   1400 saal purane desert society ko aaj ke bathroom-equipped society se compare karna non-sense hai.
5. Ignorance of Islamic Cleanliness Teachings
   Islam me poora ek bab hai: Book of Purification, jisme cleanliness ka proper system diya gaya hai.
6. WhatsApp Knowledge Syndrome
   Objector ne superficial knowledge se judgement diya, na ke real Islamic fiqh ya hygiene system ko samjha.
7. Rigveda Par Chuppi
   Jab same level ka controversial text Hindu scripture se dikhaya gaya, to objector silent ho gaya — clear bias.

Kya Menstruation Wali Hadith Ghalat Hygiene Sikhati Hai? Ka Final Jawab

Final Thoughts
Islam ka hygiene system duniya ke sabse pehle aur sabse advanced systems me se hai. Menstruation wali Hadith hygiene ko compromise nahi karti, balki poverty me bhi safai ka tariqa batati hai. Jo log bas WhatsApp par padhe objections se Islam pe attack karte hain, unko pehle apni books ka level dekhna chahiye. Jab tak insaaf se dono taraf nahi dekhoge, na sach samajh paoge, na insaniyat.