Kya 7th Century Ka Quran Na Milna Uski Hifazat Ko Jhutlata Hai?
Objection Explained
Ek objector ne kaha: “Agar Quran sach me Allah ka kalam hai to uska 7th century ka likhit nuskha kyu nahi milta? Jab tak physical manuscript nahi milti, Quran ki hifazat ka dawa kaise maana jaye?” Is objection ka base purely Western secular logic hai — jahan sirf likhi cheez hi saboot mani jati hai.
Quran Preservation Debate – Is Old Manuscript Essential?
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya: Quran ki hifazat ka asli tareeqa oral tawatur hai. Har daur me hazaroon log lafz-ba-lafz Quran yaad rakhte aaye hain. Likhi hui copy (manuscript) sirf secondary proof hai. Agar likhit copy khatam bhi ho jaye, to bhi Quran zinda rehta hai, kyunki uska lafz ummat ke seene me mehfooz hai.
Quran Preservation Debate – Logical & Historical Proof
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne debate me ye logical points diye:
- Oral Tawatur = Real Preservation: Quran ek zinda kitab hai jo har generation ke hafizon ke zariye lafz-ba-lafz transmit hui hai.
- Secondary Role of Manuscripts: Quran ke likhe hue nuskhe important hain, lekin asli hifazat ka zariya oral tradition hai.
- Compilation in Prophet’s Lifetime: Quran likha gaya tha Prophet ﷺ ke daur me bhi, aur Hazrat Uthman ke zamanay me officially compile hua.
- No Versions – Just One Quran: Duniya ke har mulk me ek hi lafz, ek hi Quran, ek hi pronunciation — ye kisi aur kitab me nahi.
- Unmatched Memorization System: Hazaron hafiz har saal paida hote hain, jo Quran ko har lafz ke saath yaad rakhte hain.
- Other Religions Lack This: Bible, Vedas ya Torah me na oral tawatur hai, na identical lafz — fir bhi follow kiya jata hai.
Quran Preservation Debate – Objection Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Written Obsession: Har cheez ko likhit roop me dhoondhna hi saboot nahi hota.
- Double Standards: Bible aur Vedas ke ancient copies nahi milti, fir bhi log unhe maante hain.
- Oral Transmission Ignored: Quran ka unique oral system ignore karna academic dishonesty hai.
- Misunderstanding of Preservation: Preservation ka matlab sirf paper par likha rehna nahi hota — lafzon ka transfer zyada authentic hai.
- Assumption of Loss: 7th century copy ka na milna loss nahi, balki natural hai (paper decay, wars, geography).
- Anti-Islam Bias: Aise objections sirf Islam ko target karte hain, dusri religions se ye sawaal nahi kiya jata.
Quran Preservation Debate – Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Quran ki hifazat ka sabse powerful system hai – tawatur. Har daur me laakhon log usse bina galti ke yaad karte aaye hain. Manuscript ka hona ek extra cheez hai, zaroorat nahi. Is objection me na logic hai, na history ka ilm. Quran wahi hai jo Muhammad ﷺ ne diya — aur wahi duniya bhar ke hafizon ke seene me hai.
