Kya English Na Aane Wale Atheist Ko Jawab De Sakte Hain?

Objection Explained
Ek student ne ye concern raise kiya ke unhone apni taleem Urdu, Arabic aur Farsi me hasil ki hai — lekin Islam par objections zyada tar English language me hote hain. Atheists ya Islam ke critics English terms me objection uthate hain, lekin non-English speakers ko unki “ilhaad” ya reasoning samajh nahi aati. To kya English na jaane wale un objections ka jawab de sakte hain?

English Nahi Aati To Atheist Ko Kaise Rokein? – SHORT me Jawab

Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke language barrier koi barrier nahi hota, asli cheez ma’loomat aur ilm ka darja hota hai. English seekhna acha hai, lekin agar aap Arabic-Urdu me Islamic base clear kar chuke hain, to aap gradually atheist objections samajh bhi sakte hain aur jawab bhi de sakte hain — bas inferiority complex ko khatam karna hoga.

English Na Hone Ka Hal Kya Hai? – Mufti Yasir Ka Tafseeli Jawab

Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne student ki concern ko appreciate kiya aur kaha:

• Ilm ek tadreeji safar hai — jaise aap Arabic me “gardan” se start karte hain, waise hi English me Islamic philosophy aur objections ka vocabulary gradually seekhna chahiye.
• Islamic madaris me agar waqt ho to ek chhota sa English-Islamic vocabulary course introduce hona chahiye — jisme atheism, agnosticism, materialism, empiricism jaise key concepts ka mutala ho.
• Unhone yeh bhi bataya ke aaj kal ke atheist arguments repetitive aur shallow hote ja rahe hain — unse ghabraane ki zarurat nahi.
• Sabse badi baat: “Ehsaas-e-kamtri” (inferiority complex) ko dil se nikaal do. Sirf is liye ke koi English me baat karta hai, iska matlab ye nahi ke uski baat deeper hai.
• Aapko apni language me strong base banana hoga — uske baad gradually English objections ko samajhna mushkil nahi rahega.

Is Objection Me Kya Kya Ghalatiyan Hain?

Objection Flaws

1. Language = Knowledge Fallacy
   Sirf English aana ka matlab yeh nahi ke kisi ko ilm ya hujjat bhi aati hai.
2. Overestimation of Opponents
   Aksar atheists ki reasoning sirf superficial hoti hai — deep ilm unke paas nahi hota.
3. Underestimating Traditional Scholars
   Non-English scholars ko kamzor samajhna unke ilm aur hujjat ki tauheen hai.
4. Ignoring Translation Path
   Aaj ki duniya me her concept ka tarjuma aur explanation available hai — aap seekh sakte ho agar niyyat ho.
5. Assuming One-Time Learning
   Ilm ek dynamic process hai. Aap gradually atheist terminology aur logic seekh kar response develop kar sakte ho.
6. Complex Se Decision Lena
   Apne ilm ko bekaar samajhna sirf society ke pressure ki wajah se hota hai — jabke asal kaam yaqeen aur sabr ka hota hai.

Ilm Aur Yaqeen Ka Taluq Zabaan Se Nahi – Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
Islam ka dushman kabhi English me bolta hai, kabhi French me — lekin haq ki zubaan sirf dalil aur ilm hoti hai. Agar aap ke paas Quran, Hadith, aur logic ka strong foundation hai, to aap kisi bhi zubaan ke shakhs ko samjha sakte ho. Mufti Yasir ka paighaam clear tha: English seekhna zaroori hai, lekin kamtari ka ehsaas sabse zyada nuqsan deh hai. Ilm ki journey ko rukne na do — aur har fild me apni ahmiyat samjho.