Allah Ki Qudrat Par Logical Paheli — Objection Explained
Atheist/ex-Muslim ka objection: “Kya Allah itna powerful hai ke ek aisa patthar bana de jo khud bhi na utha sake?” Log phas jaate hain — agar “haan” kaha to Allah kamzor ho gaya, agar “na” kaha to Allah ki qudrat mukammal nahi rahi. Aise sawal college aur university students ko confuse kar dete hain, isliye kai log mazhab chhodne tak ki baatein sochne lagte hain.
Kya Allah Aisa Patthar Bana Sakta Hai? — Short Answer
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir kehte hain: Yeh objection khud logical nahi, balke paheli hai. Allah ki qudrat mukammal hai, magar Allah ki qudrat se wohi cheezen mumkin hain jo logically mumkin hoon. Koi bhi aisi cheez banana jiska hona hi namumkin hai (jaise ek aisa patthar jo Allah utha nahi sakta), yeh Allah ki qudrat ka naqis hona nahi — balke sawal hi ghalat hai!
Logical Paheli Ka Islam Mein Jawab — Detailed Answer
Detailed Answer
- Mufti Yasir ne bataya: Creator aur Creation ka relation ek nizaam ke tahat hai. Allah har cheez par qudrat rakhta hai, magar sirf wohi cheez logical hai jo creation ki category mein aati hai.
- Example: Jaise Suraj ki roshni — kuch cheezein us roshni ko absorb karti hain (jaise kaagaz), kuch nahi karti (jaise sound waves). Iska matlab yeh nahi ke Suraj mein kami hai, balke un cheezen ka apna nature hai.
- Patthar ka objection: “Aisa patthar jo Allah na utha sake,” yeh concept hi logically invalid hai. Kyunki Allah har mumkin cheez bana sakta hai, lekin logical contradictions (jaise square circle, ya khud ki qudrat ko limit karna) Allah ki perfection se taluq nahi rakhti.
- Summary: Yeh sawal philosophical trap hai. Allah ki qudrat complete hai, logical contradictions us par lagu nahi hote.
Is Objection Ki Logical Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Category Mistake: Allah ki qudrat sirf mumkin cheezon par hai — logical contradictions (jaise square circle) cheezen hain hi nahi.
- False Dilemma: Question aise pesh kiya gaya hai ke dono jawab Allah ki qudrat par shaq dalte hain, jab ke asal mein sawal hi bekaar hai.
- Paheli Par Bunyad: Objection logical argument nahi, balki trick question hai — maqsad confuse karna hai.
- Creation/Creator Ka Nizaam: Creator ka role creation se alag hai; Allah har mumkin cheez bana sakta hai, magar apni qudrat ko khud hi restrict karna logical nahi.
- Science Ka Example Ghalat Use Karna: Jaise Suraj ki roshni sound waves par effect nahi karti, usi tarah logical contradictions Allah ki qudrat par apply nahi hoti.
Allah Ki Qudrat, Human Logic Se Aage — Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Yeh objection sirf confuse karne ke liye hota hai, asal ilm aur logic ka taluq nahi. Allah ki qudrat har mumkin cheez par hai, magar logical contradictions (jo mumkin hi nahi) us ka hisa nahi. Islam humein sikhata hai — fake philosophical traps ki bajaye asli ilm aur logic ki taraf aao. Socho: logical paheliyon ke chakkar me na phanso, khuda ka maqam insani logic se bahut ooncha hai!
