Kya Nature Khud Creator Ho Sakta Hai? | Islamic Logic vs Atheist Logic

Kya Nature Khud Creator Hai?

Objection Explained
Atheist/ex-Muslim ne objection uthaya: “Main nature ko hi creator maanta hoon, Allah ya koi creator alag se nahi hai.” Unka kehna hai ki jo kuch bhi ho raha hai, sab nature ki wajah se ho raha hai — Allah ki zarurat hi nahi. Unhone poocha: Suraj, hawa, samundar — kya yeh sab bas randomly hain ya Allah ne banaya hai?

Nature Creator Hai Ya Allah? — Short Answer

Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya: Nature apne aap koi cheez nahi kar sakta, har makhluq (like suraj, hawa, samundar) ek nizaam ke tahat chal rahi hai. Yeh sab cheezein insaan ki zarurat ke liye hain, insaan in cheezon ke liye nahi bana. Nature ka logic khud incomplete hai — asal creator Allah hi hai jo sab kuch control karta hai.

Islamic View: Nature Ka Logic vs Allah Ki Taqdeer — Detailed Answer

Detailed Answer

• Mufti Yasir kehte hain: Suraj, chand, hawa, samundar — sab ek fixed duty par hain. Jaise koi employee ko joining letter milta hai, waise in cheezon ko Allah ne ek role diya hai.
• Yeh makhluqat insaan ki zarurat ke liye hai. Insaan agar na bhi rahe, yeh cheezein exist karengi — lekin agar in me se koi cheez na ho, to insaan reh nahi sakta. Isse prove hota hai ki insaan dependent hai, nature par nahi, balki Allah ke nizaam par.
• Nature ko creator samajhna ek childish logic hai, kyunki nature ka khud koi irada nahi hai, koi will nahi hai. Nature ko bhi kisi ne set kiya hai, aur wo hai Allah.
• Objection wale bhagte hain jab unse proof maanga jaye. Unke paas clear dalil nahi hoti, sirf statements hoti hain.
• Islam me har makhluq ki expiry date Allah ke hukum se hai, insaan ki marzi se nahi.

Nature Ko Creator Maanne Ka Logic — Kya Galatiyan Hain?

Objection Flaws

1. Cause and Effect Ignore Karna: Nature khud se kuch nahi karta, har effect ka ek cause hota hai — wo Allah hai.
2. Dependent/Independent Confusion: Insaan nature pe depend karta hai, lekin nature insaan pe nahi. Yani, insaan central nahi, Allah ka nizaam central hai.
3. No Evidence, Sirf Statement: Jo log nature ko creator kehte hain, wo logical proof nahi dete, sirf claim karte hain.
4. Childish Comparison: Bachon jaisa logic hai — jaise “Suraj kyun nikalta hai?” Bas aise hi hai.
5. Nature Ka Will Nahi: Nature ka apna irada nahi, kuch bhi randomly nahi hota. Sab Allah ke hukum se hai.
6. Expiry Date Ignore Karna: Har cheez ki expiry date Allah ne fix ki hai, nature ki marzi se nahi.

Islamic Creator vs Nature — Aakhri Baat

Final Thoughts
Insaan jab tak Allah ke nizaam ko samajh nahi pata, usko lagta hai sab random hai ya nature ka khel hai. Islam yeh sikhata hai ke har makhluq, har cheez, ek system se chal rahi hai jo sirf Allah control karta hai. Nature khud kuch nahi, asal taqat Allah hai. Socho — jab proof maanga gaya, nature walon ke paas koi jawab nahi tha. Aap khud decide karo: solid logic kis taraf hai?