Kya Muslim PM Ban Kar Shariah Law Nafiz Kar Sakta Hai?
Objection Explained
Ek hypothetical sawal uthaya gaya: agar ek practicing Muslim, jaise Mufti Yasir jaise shakhs, India ka Prime Minister ban jaye — to kya wo Shariah law lagayega? Kya uska asli maqsad Islam ko officially enforce karna hoga, ya fir secular constitution ke tahat hi kaam karega?
Muslim Prime Minister Kya Shariah Nafiz Kar Sakta Hai?
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne kaha ke India ka har citizen — Hindu ho ya Muslim — ek constitutional contract ke tahat rehta hai. Agar koi Muslim PM banta hai, to wo bhi isi contract ke tahat operate karega. Jab tak Constitution secular hai, us shakhs ko bhi usi ke tahat kaam karna hoga. Sirf tabhi change laa sakta hai jab public usse vote de specifically shariah implementation ke liye.
Agar Muslim PM Ban Gaya To Kya Shariah Laa Sakta Hai?
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne samjhaya ke India me citizenship ek mutual contract hai — jo Constitution ke tahat banta hai. Chahe koi Muslim PM ban jaye, wo bhi isi contract ka part hoga. Isliye uska farz hoga ke wo har citizen ke right ko protect kare, aur existing secular Constitution ke under kaam kare.
Agar kisi Muslim leader ka intention hota ke wo Constitution change kare aur shariah law enforce kare, to usse yeh openly declare karna hoga — election manifesto me. Aur agar public ne usse usi promise pe vote diya ho, to wo tabhi change laa sakta hai.
Lekin agar vote development, security, ya welfare pe liya gaya ho, aur baad me shariah laane ki koshish ki jaaye, to wo betrayal hoga — logon ke trust ka. Democracy me public will hi asli mandate hoti hai.
Muslim PM Ko Shariah Nafiz Karne Se Kya Rokta Hai?
Objection Flaws
- Contractual Ignorance: Jo Muslim PM banega, wo bhi secular Constitution ka hi hissa hoga — aur usi ke rules follow karne honge.
- Wrong Expectation: Islam ka matlab yeh nahi ke har Muslim ruler shariah enforce kare, regardless of the system.
- Democracy Misunderstood: Public mandate secular ho, lekin leader Islamic rule lagaye — yeh ethical betrayal hoga.
- No Hidden Agenda: Agar kisi ne shariah ka wada nahi kiya election me, to wo usay laa bhi nahi sakta.
- Contract Is Not Sacred But Binding: Constitution sacred nahi, lekin legally binding hai jab tak citizenship usi pe based hai.
- Shariah Requires Consent: Islam bhi zulm ke against hai — kisi par zabardasti hukumat nahi ki ja sakti jab tak log usay freely accept na karein.
- False Assumption of Power: PM hone ka matlab yeh nahi ke har decision uski marzi se ho — system me checks and balances hote hain.
Kya Shariah Tab Laayi Ja Sakti Hai Jab Muslim Majority Vote De?
Final Thoughts
Islam me hukumat ek zimmedari hai — power nahi. Agar kisi Muslim PM ko logon ne clear majority vote diya ho shariah ke liye, tabhi wo system badal sakta hai. Warna, wo bhi wahi secular structure follow karega jiska hissa ban kar wo kursi tak pohcha hai. Islam me contract todna haram hai — aur Constitution bhi ek aisa hi muahida hai jab tak insaan us mulk ka shehri ho. Isliye Muslim PM bhi apne faith aur public responsibility ke darmiyan balance rakhta hai — honesty ke sath.
