OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Allah Musalmano Ki Madad Duniya Me Kyun Nahi Karta?
Agnostic objector ne question uthaya ke agar Allah sab kuch dekh raha hai, to Palestine, Afghanistan jaise Muslim regions me zulm kyun ho raha hai? Musalman Allah ke follower hain, phir bhi unki koi special madad dikhayi nahi deti. Unhone compare kiya ke non-Muslim nations economically aur politically zyada stable hain, jabke Muslim nations crisis me hain. Is basis par unhone Islam aur divine help ke concept ko illogical declare kar diya.
SHORT ANSWER – Allah ki madad duniya me kyun nahi dikhayi deti?
Duniya test center hai, reward center nahi. Allah sabko test karta hai — Muslim ya non-Muslim sab. Madad usi qoum ko milti hai jo tayyari karti hai. Sirf Muslim hone se Allah ka favoured treatment nahi milta.
DETAILED ANSWER – Musalman hone ke bawajood duniya me takleef kyun?
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke duniya reward ka jagah nahi hai — ye test center hai. Quran me Allah ne clear kar diya ke wo sabko test karega: life, death, loss, aur fear ke zariye. Jo log test me pass hote hain, unka reward aakhiraat me fix hai.
Palestine, Afghanistan aur doosri jagahon ki musibat sirf unka test nahi hai — Muslims ki global zimmedari bhi hai. Agar Muslims ready nahi honge (technologically, intellectually, militarily), to Allah ki madad nahi aayegi. Quran me clear hai: “Allah us qoum ki halat nahi badalta jab tak wo khud apni halat na badlein.”
Mufti ne example diya ke 400 saal pehle Muslims superpower the, kyun? Kyunki wo tayyari karte the. Aaj Jews aur Christians powerful hain, kyunki wo mehnat kar rahe hain. Is duniya me Allah ka system merit-based hai, biased nahi.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Agnostic argument ki logical galtiyaan
- Fallacy 1: Emotional Reasoning
- Objector ne emotional examples (Palestine, Afghanistan) use kiye bina Quranic ya theological framework samjhe. Logic se zyada grief-driven reasoning thi.
- Fallacy 2: Misunderstanding Divine Justice
- Yeh assume kiya gaya ke Allah ka justice duniya me hi dikhna chahiye, jabke Islamic view me asli justice aakhiraat me hota hai.
- Fallacy 3: False Equivalence
- Objector ne Muslims ke failures ko Islam ke concept of divine help se equate kiya, jabke Quran me madad ke liye effort aur obedience ka shart hai.
- Fallacy 4: Selective Observation
- Sirf conflict regions ko example banaya gaya, lekin Muslim countries jahan peace hai (Malaysia, Qatar, Indonesia) unka zikr nahi kiya gaya.
- Fallacy 5: Ignoring Universal Test Model
- Yeh baat ignore ki gayi ke non-Muslim nations bhi disaster, war, aur poverty face karte hain — test sabke liye hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Duniya me test aur aakhiraat me reward ka concept
Musalman hone ka matlab ye nahi ke bina effort ke reward milega. Allah ka system fair hai — har qoum ko uski mehnat ke mutabiq milega. Musalman agar tayyari chhod de to unhe bhi consequences face karne padenge. Real success un logon ke liye hai jo duniya me mehnat bhi karein aur akhirat ke liye bhi ready hoon.
