OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Allah Ne Insaan Ko Banaya Hi Kyun Jab Usse Pata Tha Ke Log Jahannam Jayenge?
Ek objector ne ye sawaal uthaya ke agar Allah sab kuch jaanta hai, aur use pata tha ke bohot saare log uska inkaar karenge, shirk karenge, aur akhirat me jahannam me jayenge — to phir unhe banaya hi kyun? Kya ye unfair nahi ke Allah ne aise log create kiye jinke bare me pehle se pata tha ke wo fail honge?
SHORT ANSWER – Allah ne creation ko sirf result ke base pe nahi, test aur justice ke liye design kiya
Allah har shakhs ko free will deta hai. Uska ilm future ka hai, lekin woh kisi ko majboor nahi karta. Test ke liye duniya banayi gayi hai — jahan har shakhs ko equal chance milta hai. Agar sirf is base pe ke koi fail hoga, usko na banaya jaye — to yeh justice nahi, bias hoga.
DETAILED ANSWER – Kya Allah ne Jahannami Logon ko Jan Boojh Kar Banaya?
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke ye objection Allah ke ilm aur uske justice ke beech confusion pe based hai. Allah ka ilm perfect hai — wo jaanta hai ke kaun kya karega. Lekin ilm aur irada (will) alag cheezein hain. Jaise ek teacher ko pata hota hai ke kaun fail karega, lekin wo phir bhi sabko test me daalta hai taake insaaf ho.
Agar Allah sirf apne ilm ki wajah se kuch logon ko create hi na karta, to baaki log kehte ke hume test ka mauka hi nahi mila. Allah har shakhs ko zindagi, guidance, reason aur truth ke exposure ka equal chance deta hai. Har banda khud choose karta hai — jannat ya jahannam ka raasta.
Aakhirat ka reward ya punishment sirf usi pe milega jo deliberately Allah ke message ko ignore karega. Ye duniya ek open test hai, jisme har banda apna raasta khud design karta hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Jahannam ke Ilm par Creation objection me logical problems
- Fallacy 1: Knowledge = Cause Assumption – Sirf Allah ka pata hona kisi ka action ka cause nahi banta.
- Fallacy 2: Denial of Free Will – Objector ye assume karta hai ke Allah ka ilm insaan ki choice ko control karta hai.
- Fallacy 3: Teacher Analogy Missed – Jaise teacher sab students ko exam me daalta hai despite knowing the outcome, Allah bhi har shakhs ko fair test deta hai.
- Fallacy 4: Justice Without Trial – Kisi ko unka result batakar test me daalne ka haq na dena injustice hoga.
- Fallacy 5: Ignoring Equal Opportunity – Har shakhs ko reason aur truth ka exposure milta hai — ye fairness ka part hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Allah Ka Ilm Perfect Hai, Magar Uska Insaaf Bhi Perfect Hai
Allah kisi ko bas is base pe jahannam me nahi bhejta ke usko pehle se pata tha. Har shakhs ka hisaab uske action se hota hai, na ke sirf potential se. Allah ka system justice pe base karta hai — proof, niyyat, aur amal ke base pe. Ye duniya har shakhs ke liye ek imtihaan hai, aur har banda us imtihaan me apni kitaab khud likhta hai.
