KYA UCC Sirf Rasmon Tak Mehdood Hai? Arif Mohammad Khan Ko Mufti Yasir Ka Jawaab

OBJECTION EXPLAINED – UCC Muslims Ke “Taur-Tareeqon” Ko Nahi, Sirf Law Ko Target Karta Hai?

Arif Mohammad Khan ne TV interview me claim kiya ke Uniform Civil Code (UCC) sirf “taur tareeqon” ko unify karta hai, aur kisi ke religion me dakhal nahi deta. Unka kehna tha ke jaise Hindus ke bhi alag tareeqe hain lekin ek act un par lagu hai, waise hi Muslims par bhi UCC lagu ho sakta hai bina unki religious practices badle.

SHORT ANSWER – KYA UCC Sirf Traditions Ko Touch Karta Hai?

Nahi. UCC ka asar traditions ya rasm-o-riwaj par nahi, balki Islamic personal law par hota hai — jaise talaq, virasat, aur nikah ke shari‘ ahkaam. Arif Mohammad Khan jaise log deliberately confuse karte hain law aur culture ke concepts ko. Islam me ‘deen’ sirf andar ki cheez nahi, balki poora system hai — andar bhi aur bahar bhi.

DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir Ka Tafsili Jawaab Arif Mohammad Khan Ko

1. Culture aur Law ka Fark:
   Mufti Yasir ne wazeh kiya ke “taur tareeqe” aur “laws” do alag concepts hain. Law ka matlab hota hai authority-based rule, jaise talaq ka haqq sirf mard ke paas hona. Rasm ye hoti hai ke shaadi ke waqt mehndi ka function kaise hoga — UCC rasmon ko nahi, Islamic legal rights ko target karta hai.
2. Shari’at ka Scope:
   Islam ke andar ibadat hi nahi, nikah, talaq, virasat, sazaaon tak ka poora legal structure hai. Jab UCC Muslims par lagu hoga, to wo unki shari’at par direct tasarruf karega. Arif Khan jese liberal face ye point chhupa lete hain.
3. Arif Mohammad Khan Ki Wada Khilafi:
   Mufti Yasir ne yaad dilaya ke 2017 me Arif Khan ne kaha tha agar koi unka ek Hadith ka ghalat tarjuma sabit kar de to wo public speaking chhod denge. Jab Mufti Yasir ne wo sabit kar diya, to bhi unhone takreer karna band nahi kiya. Ye unki credibility pe sawal uthata hai.
4. Ek Ummah, Multiple Cultures:
   Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke duniya bhar me Muslims ke “taur tareeqe” alag ho sakte hain (jaise Turkey aur Central Asia ke log ghode ka gosht khate hain), lekin Shari‘at ke legal principles sabke liye common hain — halal aur haram ka boundary clear hai.

OBJECTION FLAWS – Arif Mohammad Khan ke Claim me 5 Logical Ghaltiyan

1. Law vs Tradition Confusion:
Rasmon ka zikr karke legal intervention ko chhupane ki koshish.

2. False Equivalence:
Hindu Marriage Act ka Muslims ke Islamic law se comparison irrelevant hai — Islam me law divinely revealed hai, codified nahi.

3. Wada Khilafi:
Khud ka ek open challenge tod dena credibility khatam karta hai.

4. Intentional Liberal Misrepresentation:
Islam ko liberal values ke mutabiq modify karne ki koshish, jise Muslims reject karte hain.

5. Ignoring Ground Reality:
Muslims ko already partial freedom bhi nahi di gayi; jo kuch mila hai wo bhi UCC le lega — talaq, virasat, adoption, sab secular system ke mutabiq ho jayega.

FINAL THOUGHTS – UCC Ek Legal Attack Hai, Cultural Cosmetic Nahi

UCC koi neutral reform nahi — ye ek targeted legal imposition hai jo Muslims ke religious laws ko secular template me fit karne ki koshish karta hai. Islam ek complete code of life hai, na ke sirf cultural symbol. Jab Arif Mohammad Khan jese log UCC ko innocently present karte hain, wo asal problem ko hide karte hain. Mufti Yasir ne ye baat clear kar di ke Islam ka nizam compromise nahi karta — na andar ka, na bahar ka.