Kya Religion Sirf Imagination Hai?

Objection Explained
Ek atheist ne kaha ke religion sirf ek “imagined order” hai jo purane zamane ke logon ne society me discipline banane ke liye banaya. Usne Yuval Noah Harari ki kitab “Sapiens” ka reference diya jahan religion ko fiction bola gaya. Iske ilawa usne pucha: agar God hai to usne hume free will kyun di? Aur life ka purpose kya hai?

Kya Religion Fiction Hai? | SHORT Me Jawab

Short Answer
Religion ko fiction kehna khud ek assumption hai. Agar religion sirf ek social order hota to duniya me sirf ek religion hota, contradictory faiths nahi. Free will aur life ka purpose sirf religion hi logically define karta hai — atheist system khud contradiction me pad jata hai.

Teen Mushkil Sawalon Ka Point-to-Point Jawab

Detailed Answer

1. Religion is an imagined order?
   Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke ye sirf ek “hypothesis” hai — koi evidence nahi. Harari ki kitab fiction hai, jisme khud assumptions hain. Agar religion insano ka banaya hua system hota, to itne contradictory religions na hote. Society me moral order ke liye sirf ek model hota.
2. Why did God give humans free will?
   Mufti Yasir ne kaha: agar God sirf good nature wale robots banata to wo real beings nahi hote. Free will hi real test hai. Atheist khud freedom ko ideal manta hai, to free will ko reject karna unke apne system ke khilaf hai.
3. What is the purpose of life?
   Jab har cheez (food, clothes, travel) ka purpose hota hai, to life ka kyun nahi? Religion har waqt ek purpose batata hai. Atheist jab kehta hai “life ka purpose sirf jeena hai”, to wo circular argument ban jata hai. Jeena jeene ke liye koi logical explanation nahi deta.

Imagination Theory Ka Logical Analysis

Objection Flaws

1. No Evidence Fallacy – Atheist ka claim sirf assumption hai, koi real proof nahi.
2. Self-contradiction – Atheists khud free will aur freedom ko ideal mante hain, fir God ke free will dene pe objection kyun?
3. False Uniformity – Agar religion man-made hota, to sirf ek version hota, contradictory beliefs nahi.
4. Circular Logic – Life ka purpose “sirf jeena” kehna, purpose ka jawab nahi — repetition hai.
5. Selective Skepticism – Atheist religious texts ko fiction kehte hain, lekin apne secular authors ki assumptions ko fact treat karte hain.

Free Will Aur Purpose Pe Sawalon Ka Logic | Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
Aaj ka atheist modern logic ka naam lekar khud contradictions me phas jata hai. Mufti Yasir ne ye clear kiya ke jab tak aap ke paas solid reasoning na ho, tab tak religion ko sirf fiction keh dena illogical hai. Har insaan sochta hai: mai kyun zinda hoon? Kahan ja raha hoon? Ye sawal religion ke bina jawab nahi paata.