OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Bacchon Ko Jannat Mile Bina Test Ke, Kya Ye Na-Insafi Hai?
Ek objector ne sawaal uthaya ke chhote bacche jo mar jaate hain aur bina kisi test ke Jannat me chale jaate hain, kya ye un adults ke sath na-insafi nahi hai jo zindagi bhar test dete hain? Uska kehna tha ke agar test ke bina reward mil gaya to baaki logon ke liye ye unfair system hua. Mufti Yasir se is objection ka jawab liya gaya.
SHORT ANSWER – JANNAT BACCHON KO MILNE KA MATALEB YE NAHI KE BAQI LOGON KE SAATH NA-INSAFI HUI
Mufti Yasir ne kaha: Jannat ek reward hai, lekin kisi aur ke reward se agar aapka reward kam nahi hua, to usme na-insafi nahi hoti. Bacche kisi ka haq nahi cheente. Allah apni Jannat ka Malik hai, wo jise chahe apne fadl se de. Ye kisi adult ke haq ka violation nahi hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Allah Ka Fadl Aur Insaf Dono Ek Saath Kaise Kaam Karte Hain
Mufti Yasir ne objector ke sawaal ko logically break kiya. Unhone poocha: Na-insafi kya hoti hai? Agar kisi ka haq chheen liya jaye, to wo na-insafi hoti hai. Lekin agar Allah kisi ko bina test ke apni Jannat me le jaye — bina kisi aur ka reward kam kiye — to ye na-insafi kaise ho gayi?
Unhone kaha ke agar bacche ke Jannat me jaane se kisi aur ki Jannat chhinti hoti, to objection valid hota. Lekin Jannat me jagah ki koi kami nahi. Na koi line kam hui, na kisi ka maqam gira.
Iske alawa, Mufti Yasir ne ye bhi clarify kiya ke Allah ke do attributes hain: Adl (Justice) aur Fadl (Grace). Adl test ke basis par hota hai, jabke Fadl bina kisi test ke bhi ho sakta hai. Allah ka apne kisi banday par grace dikhana kisi doosre ke haq ko affect nahi karta.
Unhone ek analogy bhi di: Ek ghar ka malik agar kisi mehmaan ko apne ghar bula le bina kisi formality ke, to kya baaki guests ka haq maar gaya? Nahi — uska apna haq hai ke wo kisko invite kare.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Bacchon Ko Jannat Milne Par Na-insafi Ka Argument Ghalat Kyun Hai?
Fallacy 1: False Comparison With Exam Results
Objector ne bacchon ke Jannat me jaane ko ek paper leak jaisa treat kiya, jabke yahan kisi ka seat ya reward occupy nahi hua.
Fallacy 2: Misunderstanding of Divine Ownership
Jannat Allah ka ghar hai — wo jise chahe de. Human exams ke rules ko divine rewards par apply karna ghalat hai.
Fallacy 3: Ignoring the Nature of Fadl (Grace)
Allah sirf insaf nahi karta, kabhi kabhi apne fadl se bhi deta hai. Is grace ko injustice kehna flawed logic hai.
Fallacy 4: No Proof of Harm to Others
Na-insafi tab hoti hai jab kisi ka haq chheena jaaye. Bacchon ke reward se kisi adult ka loss nahi hua.
Fallacy 5: Wrong Analogy With Government Recruitment
Sports minister aur chairperson examples irrelevant hain, kyunke ye world-based comparison hai, Jannat eternal reward hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Bacchon Ko Jannat Milna Na-insafi Nahi, Allah Ka Rahm Hai
Is duniya me har cheez test pe based nahi hoti. Kabhi kabhi sirf rahm, hikmat aur divine mercy ka kaam hota hai. Allah har ek ke haal se waaqif hai. Jannat kisi ki mehnat se chhin jaaye to objection banta hai, lekin jab kisi ka haq chhina hi nahi, to objection khud be-maani ho jata hai. Mufti Yasir ne ye sab logical tarike se samjhaya.
