Kya Quran Ka 7th Century Manuscript Na Milna Uski Hifazat Ko Jhutlata Hai?
Objection Explained
Ek atheist objector ne Mufti Yasir se poocha: “Agar Quran waqai Allah ka lafz hai aur hifazat ka wada hai, to phir 7th century ka ek bhi complete manuscript kyun nahi milta? Agar Quran ko Allah ne protect kiya hota, to physical copies ka saboot to milta hi.” Yeh objection Quran ki hifazat ke concept ko sirf likhit (written) nuskho tak mehdood samajhne ki koshish karta hai.
Kya Quran Ki Hifazat Sirf Manuscript Par Depend Karti Hai?
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke Quran ki hifazat sirf physical manuscripts se nahi hoti — balki tawatur (mutawatir oral transmission) se hoti hai. Islam me likhit text secondary hai, asli hifazat zubani silsile (hafz) ke zariye hoti hai — jo har daur me uninterrupted chala aaya hai. Har ek lafz, har ek harf hazaaron logon ke zariye yaad rakha gaya hai.
Quran Ka Mahfooz Hona: Manuscript Nahin, Tawatur Se
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne debate me clear kiya:
- Islam me Quran ki primary protection oral transmission ke zariye hui hai. Ye wahi system hai jisme har generation me hazaron log poora Quran yaad rakhte aaye hain — bina kisi gap ke.
- Jo log kehte hain ke 7th century ka complete manuscript nahi mila — wo ek secular-European lens se soch rahe hain jahan likhit text ko final authority mana jata hai.
- Islam me lughwi (linguistic) hifazat ke sath-sath tariqi (transmission) hifazat bhi hai.
- Manuscripts available hain — lekin hifazat ka proof unpe depend nahi karta.
- Mufti Yasir ne ye bhi bataya ke agar aap ye logic apply karo to Bible aur Vedas jaise texts pe to koi bhi historical authenticity bachi hi nahi.
- Quran ko likhne ka kaam Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ke zamane me hi shuru ho chuka tha, aur Caliph Uthman ke waqt officially compile bhi hua.
- Ab agar koi 7th century ka full document maange, to usse pehle yeh samajhna hoga ke har daur me oral chain intact thi — aur wahi asli security system tha.
Kya Manuscript Wale Objection Me Koi Logic Hai?
Objection Flaws
- Manuscript Obsession: Sirf likhit saboot ko evidence banana western academic bias hai.
- Oral Tradition Neglected: Quran ka oral transmission system duniya ka sabse stable system hai.
- Double Standards: Bible, Vedas ke paas to oral + written dono ka tawatur nahi — phir bhi unhe blindly accept kiya jata hai.
- Copy ≠ Content: Agar ek purani copy gum ho jaye, to iska matlab yeh nahi hota ke content gum ho gaya.
- Tawatur = Higher Standard: Hazaaron logon ka lafz-ba-lafz yaad rakhna written text se zyada reliable hai.
- Preservation ≠ Archeology: Hifazat ka matlab har zamanay ka physical copy milna nahi — balki lafz lafz wahi content aaj tak unchanged milna hai.
- Ignoring Islamic Compilation Process: Compilation Prophet ke zamane me hi start ho chuki thi, Uthman ke daur me official mushaf bana — yeh documented hai.
Quran Ki Hifazat Sirf Kitaabon Se Nahi, Hafizon Se Hoti Hai
Final Thoughts
Mufti Yasir ne objector ko logically aur academically dono level par jawab diya. Quran ki hifazat ka system duniya ke kisi bhi kitab ke comparison me sabse strong hai. Agar ek shakhs sachai se talash kare, to Quran ka tawatur, uski lafzi consistency, aur global uniformity uske ilahi hone ka zinda saboot hai. Quran ko na to tabdeel kiya ja sakta hai, na chhupaya ja sakta hai — yehi uska mo’jiza hai.
