OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Allah Powerful Hai To Duniya Me Buraai Kyun Hai?
Ek atheist ne yeh objection uthaya ke agar Allah sab kuch jaanta hai (all-knowing), sab kuch kar sakta hai (all-powerful), aur rahmat wala hai (merciful), to phir duniya me itni buraai (evil), zulm, aur takleef kyun hai? Kya Allah chahta nahi ke insaan safe aur peaceful zindagi guzaarein? Agar chahta hai to fir yeh saari musibatain kyun allow ki? Is logic ke base par wo Allah ki existence ko reject karta hai.
SHORT ANSWER – Khuda duniya me evil ko rok kyun nahi leta ka short me jawab
Agar Allah duniya me har evil ko turant rok de, to insaf aur test ka maqsad khatam ho jata. Mufti Yasir kehte hain ke Allah ne multiple worlds banaye hain – jahan sirf khair hai (Jannah), sirf shar hai (Jahannum), aur ek mix duniya (ye duniya) – jahan insaan ki testing hoti hai. Evil ka hona justice aur choice ka part hai, na ke Allah ki mercy ka nafrak.
DETAILED ANSWER – Problem of Evil ka Mufti Yasir kehta hai kya logical jawab
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke objection tabhi samajh aayega jab aap Islamic worldview ko pura consider karenge. Islam ke mutabiq:
- Allah ne duniya banayi insaan ki testing ke liye.
- Insaf tabhi ho sakta hai jab khair aur shar dono exist karein.
- Khuda ne evil create nahi kiya, usne bas allow kiya – taake insaan apni marzi se amal kare aur result paaye.
- Jo log zulm ka shikar hote hain, unke liye Allah ke pass aakhirat me compensation (reward) ka nizaam hai.
- Jo log zulm karte hain, unko bhi akhirat me saza milti hai.
- Agar duniya me koi evil na hoti, to bravery, sacrifice, patience jaise noble acts ka matlab hi na banta.
Mufti ne volcano eruption ka example diya jisme innocent log mar jaate hain. Unka kehna hai ke Allah ki wisdom (Al-Hakeem) human logic se upar hai. Har case ka result akhirat me based hota hai – ya to reward ya punishment.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Problem of Evil wale logic me kya kya ghalatiyan hain?
1. Cherry-Picking Attributes of God:
Objector sirf 2 sifatein (Mercy aur Power) uthata hai, lekin Justice aur Wisdom jaisi core attributes ko ignore karta hai.
2. Short-Term Vision:
Objection sirf duniya tak limited hai. Islam ka worldview aakhirat tak extend karta hai, jahan final justice hoti hai.
3. Confusion Between Creation vs. Performance of Evil:
Khuda ne evil create nahi kiya. Insaan hi usse perform karta hai apni choice se. Yeh testing ka part hai.
4. Logical Contradiction:
Agar har evil Allah rok de, to free will aur accountability ka concept hi khatam ho jata.
5. False Expectation of Heaven on Earth:
Objector yeh expect karta hai ke duniya Jannah ki tarah ho, jabke Islam ke mutabiq yeh duniya ek imtihaan hai – na ke reward zone.
6. Ignorance of Parallel Realms:
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke Allah ne already aise worlds banaye hain jahan sirf khair hai – Jannah, aur sirf shar – Jahannum. Yeh duniya unke darmiyan test zone hai.
7. Burden of Alternative Model:
Objector ke paas khud koi better model nahi hota jisme insaf, test, aur morality ka balance ho. Sirf Allah ke model pe objection karta hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Khuda par e’tiraz karne se pehle poori tasveer dekho
Insaan apni limited soch se Allah ki unlimited wisdom ko nahi samajh sakta. Problem of evil sirf tabhi “problem” lagta hai jab aap aakhirat ko ignore karo. Islam me har zulm ka hisaab hoga, har mazloom ko insaaf milega. Buraai ka hona khud Allah ke wujood ka nafi nahi, balki insaf aur imtihaan ka hissa hai. Agar aapko sach me justice chahiye, to aakhirat par yaqeen zaroori hai.
