Aaj kal ke digital daur me, kai influencers religious topics par apni opinion dete hain – magar kya unka knowledge bhi waqai utna gahra hota hai jitni unki reach? Jab koi shaks, sirf science ke zariye har metaphysical cheez ko jhutlata hai, to uske aqwal me contradictions aur fallacies barh jaati hain. Aisi hi ek misaal hai Dhruv Rathee jinka naam politics me kaafi mashhoor hai, lekin religion aur God par unke comments unki samajh ki gehraayi par sawal uthate hain.
Is article me hum logical aur Islamic nazariye se analyze karenge ke kya unka stance “God doesn’t exist” waqai rational hai, ya ek superficial conclusion? Kya religion sirf emotional support ka zariya hai, ya iske peechay sachai bhi hai? Kya “respect” aur “denial” ek sath mumkin hain?
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways:
- Khuda ke wujood ka inkaar karne wale log aksar contradictory statements dete hain.
- Science har cheez ka jawab nahi de sakti – metaphysical realities ke liye logic aur fitrah bhi zaroori hai.
- Religion ko sirf ek social tool kehna ek False Cause Fallacy hai.
- Jo cheez logical na lage, zaroori nahi ke woh illogical ho – standard har shakhs ka alag ho sakta hai.
- Islamic nazriya logical bhi hai aur consistent bhi – especially jab baat ho Creator ki zarurat ki.
Kya God Ke Wujood Ka Sawal “Simple” Hai?
Kai log kehte hain ke “Khuda ka wujood nahi hai – simple!” Lekin jab isi sawal par unse logical reasoning mangi jaati hai to woh confuse ho jaate hain. Yeh contradiction ek logical fallacy hai jise Self-Contradiction kehte hain.
Agar ek shakhs keh raha ho:
“God ka jawab simple hai – God nahi hai. Magar yeh question complex bhi hai, isliye doosre views ki respect honi chahiye.”
To sawal yeh uthta hai: Kya sawal simple hai ya complex? Dono ek sath nahi ho sakte.
Yeh batata hai ke speaker ya to confuse hai, ya audience ko confuse karne ki koshish kar raha hai. Islam kehta hai ke Khuda ka wujood ek fitri sach hai – har insaan ke dil me Allah ki pehchan ki base mojood hoti hai.
Kya Sirf Science se Sach Ka Pata Lagta Hai?
Jo log sirf science ko knowledge ka wahid zariya samajhte hain, woh ek aur fallacy ka shikar hote hain – Scientism Fallacy.
Science ka daira sirf measurable aur observable cheezon tak hota hai. Magar:
- Kya aapki maa ki mohabbat ko laboratory me naap sakte ho?
- Kya justice, purpose, ya ethics ko test tube me daala ja sakta hai?
Jawab hamesha “nahi” hoga. To kya in cheezon ka wujood nahi? Sirf is liye ke science nahi maanti?
Islam yeh nahi kehta ke science ghalat hai. Balki kehta hai ke science apni had tak sahi hai – magar metaphysical questions jaise “Khuda hai ya nahi” ka jawab sirf science nahi de sakti. Uske liye fitrah, logic, aur revelation zaroori hai.
Kya Religion Sirf Emotional Tool Hai?
Aksar liberal thinkers yeh kehte hain ke religion logon ko sirf hope aur purpose dene ka ek zariya hai. Magar yeh argument bhi False Cause Fallacy hai.
Yani:
“Religion logon ko sukoon deta hai, isliye religion sach nahi ho sakta.”
Yeh logic kuch is tarah hai ke:
“Dawa se patient ko sukoon milta hai, isliye dawa jhoot hai.”
Islam sirf emotional tasalli ka zariya nahi, balki ek logical aur practical nizaam-e-zindagi hai. Uske aqeede, usool aur aamal har angle se consistent hain – chahe aap insani psychology se dekhein ya cosmological logic se.
Kya Logon Ko Jodne Wala Har Nizaam Mohtaram Hota Hai?
Ek aur logic diya jaata hai:
“Main religion nahi maanta, magar uski izzat karta hoon kyunke yeh logon ko jodta hai.”
To phir fasiszm, hardcore communism, ya North Korea ka dictatorship bhi izzat ke laayak hoga – kyunke unhone bhi logon ko joda.
Islam yeh kehta hai ke:
- Mohtaram woh hai jo haq pe ho.
- Har “joining system” mohtaram nahi hota – jab tak uska bunyad insaaf aur haqq pe na ho.
Yani, Bandwagon Fallacy se bachna chahiye – sirf log maan rahe hain, is liye woh cheez sahi hai, yeh logic nahi chalti.
Kya Mythology Ko History Samajhna Aqalmandi Hai?
Agar koi kahe:
“Main God nahi maanta, magar Hindu customs follow karta hoon. Mythology ko culture ke tor par samajhta hoon.”
To yeh Cognitive Dissonance hai – jab shakhs apni soch aur amal ke darmiyan munafiqana contradiction mein hota hai.
Islam ka stance clear hai: Culture us waqt tak maqbool hai jab tak woh haqq ke saath mutabiqat rakhta ho. Sirf is liye kisi cheez ko follow karna ke woh purani hai, ya logon ko pasand hai, yeh logical nahi.
Kya Logical Lagna Hi Sachai Ki Nishani Hai?
“Jo baat logical nahi lagti, woh sach nahi ho sakti.”
Yeh logic apni jagah galat hai kyunke “logical” ka matlab har shakhs ke liye alag ho sakta hai. Aapka logic aur mera logic – dono subjective ho sakte hain.
Islam yeh kehta hai:
- Haq woh hai jo universal fitrat se mutabiq ho.
- Quran hidayat deta hai – aur woh hidayat aapki logic ko bhi test karti hai, aur dil ke sukoon ko bhi.
Aksar agnostic yeh kehte hain ke:
“Agar koi baat meri logic ke khilaf ho to main use metaphor maan loonga.”
Magar sawal yeh hai: Aapki logic kahan se aayi? Modern education se ya fitrat se? Agar aap fitrat se door ho gaye ho, to aapki logic already polluted hai.
Modern Morality Ya Timeless Morality?
Aaj ke log kehte hain:
“Aaj ki moral values old religious values se behtar hain.”
Yani har naye daur ki morality best hai? Phir to kal ki morality aaj ki morality ko bekaar sabit karegi. Yehi Chronological Snobbery hai – yani har purani cheez ko sirf is liye reject kar dena ke woh purani hai.
Islam timeless morality deta hai – jo har daur, har society, aur har insaan ke liye relevant hai. Wahi aqeedah jo 1400 saal pehle tha, aaj bhi chal raha hai.
Natija: Har Field Ka Ek Specialist Hota Hai
Jese ek doctor engineering ka mashwara nahi deta, waise hi religion ka specialist woh nahi ho sakta jo sirf politics ya general knowledge ki field ka ho.
Islamic daai hone ka matlab hai: logical, consistent, aur respectful tareeke se sachai pesh karna. Jo log Islam ya religion par tanqeedi baat karein – unke paas ya to pura ilm hona chahiye, ya khamosh rehna chahiye.
FAQs
Q: Kya science God ke wujood ko deny karti hai?
A: Nahi. Science metaphysical questions ka jawab nahi deti – woh sirf physical world ko analyze karti hai. Khuda ke wujood ka masla logic aur fitrah se sabit hota hai.
Q: Kya religion sirf emotional support ke liye hota hai?
A: Nahi. Islam logical, social, aur spiritual level par mukammal guidance deta hai. Sirf sukoon nahi, balki direction aur objective bhi deta hai.
Q: Kya har successful system mohtaram hota hai?
A: Nahi. Sirf un systems ki izzat honi chahiye jo haq pe ho aur insaaf par mabni ho. Success alone izzat ka meyaar nahi hai.
Q: Kya mythology ko metaphor maan lena sahi approach hai?
A: Agar aap har logical challenge ko metaphor se bypass karte hain to aap asal sachai tak kabhi nahi pahunch sakte. Har cheez metaphor nahi hoti.
Q: Kya naye daur ki morality hamesha behtar hoti hai?
A: Nahi. Moral values timeless hoti hain jab woh fitrah aur haqq ke mutabiq hon. Har naye daur ki har baat behtar nahi hoti.
