Kya Musalman Kaaba Ki Puja Karte Hain?
Objection Explained
Ek objector ne kaha: “Muslims murti puja ke khilaf hain, lekin khud Kaaba ki taraf mooh karke sajda karte hain, usay choomte hain — to kya yeh bhi puja nahi hui?” Yeh objection Hindu rituals aur Islamic respect ke concept ko mila kar confusion paida karta hai.
Kya Kaaba Ko Choomna Ibadat Hai Ya Ehteram?
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ke mutabiq, Musalman Kaaba ki ibadat nahi karte — wo sirf Allah ki taraf mooh karte hain. Kaaba ko chumna ya izzat dena sirf Allah ki nishani hone ki wajah se hota hai. Ibadat sirf Allah ki hoti hai, Kaaba ya uske parday se kabhi kuch nahi maanga jata.
Kaaba Ki Izzat Aur Ibadat Mein Kya Farq Hai?
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne samjhaya:
- Islam me sha’airullah (Allah ki nishaniyan) ka concept hai — jaise masjid, minar, ya Kaaba.
- Kaaba ko izzat milti hai kyunki woh Allah ka ghar hai, na ke isliye ke woh Allah hai.
- Ibadat sirf us cheez ki hoti hai jise maabood maana jaye aur jisse kuch manga jaye.
- Musalman Kaaba se kuch nahi maangte — sirf Allah se maangte hain.
- Kaaba ki taraf sajda direction (qibla) ke liye hai, na ke worship ke liye.
- Hindu rituals jaise murti ko doodh chadhana, usse maangna, ya usko devta maanna — ye sab shirk hai. Islam me iski koi jagah nahi.
- Musalman kisi nishani se mohabbat aur izzat ka izhar to karte hain, lekin sirf Allah ki ibadat karte hain.
Kya Kaaba Ki Puja Wala Objection Galat Hai?
Objection Flaws
- Respect ≠ Worship: Choomna ya izzat dena ibadat nahi hoti — agar hoti to maa-baap ki khidmat bhi shirk hoti.
- No Divine Claim: Kaaba ko kabhi Allah nahi kaha gaya.
- Direction, Not Deity: Namaz Kaaba ki taraf hoti hai, lekin namaz Allah ke liye hoti hai.
- No Du’a to Kaaba: Kabhi bhi Kaaba se dua nahi maangi jaati.
- Sha’airullah Concept: Allah ke nishaniyon ka izzat karna Quran se sabit hai.
- Hadith Proof: Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ne khud kaha: “Yeh Kaaba Allah ki nishani hai, iski ibadat nahi.”
- Emotional Projection Fallacy: Objector ne Hindu rituals ka comparison Muslim practices se isliye kiya kyunki unka worship concept physical imagery se juda hai.
Musalman Kaaba Ko Qibla Mante Hain, Maabood Nahi
Final Thoughts
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke Kaaba ek sacred direction hai, na ke worship ka object. Muslim sirf Allah ki ibadat karte hain. Agar koi kisi cheez se mohabbat kare, ya uska kiss lena izzat ka izhar ho, to wo shirk nahi ban jata. Shirk tab hota hai jab us cheez ko rab samjha jaye. Kaaba izzat ke laayak hai — ibadat ke nahi.
