Kya Gali Dene Wale Ko Muslim Bhi Gali De Sakta Hai?

Objection Explained
Is video me ek objector ne Mufti Yasir ke panel me aake directly “munaafiq” keh diya. Ye objection asal me ye demand karta hai ke jab aapko koi provoke kare, to aap bhi utni hi sakhti se jawab dein. Ye soch ye imply karti hai ke harshness ka jawab harshness se dena chahiye — warna aap kamzor ya defensive samjhe jaate hain.

Gali Ka Jawab Gali? – SHORT me Jawab

Short Answer
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke Islam me bad-tameezi ka jawab rationality aur akhlaaq se diya jata hai — na ke utni hi bad-tameezi se. Jo tum keh rahe ho uska jawab tum khud Allah ke saamne doge, hum nahi. Yeh emotional control aur Islamic akhlaaq ka saboot hai.

Mufti Yasir Ka Approach – Hikmat Aur Akhlaaq Ka Model

Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne pehle objector ko bolne diya, usse interrupt nahi kiya. Jab usne “munaafiq” keh diya, to Mufti sahab ne calmly jawab diya:

“Jo kehna hai keh lo, tumhare lafzon ka jawab tum Allah ke saamne doge, hum nahi.”

Ye jawab emotionally intelligent tha. Unhone yeh bhi kaha ke agar koi gussa mein kuch keh raha hai, to hum uski mental condition par sirf hamdardi ka izhar kar sakte hain — lekin utna hi ganda jawab de kar Islam ka level neeche nahi gira sakte.

Unhone Rasool Allah ﷺ ka example diya — jab unpe “sahir”, “majnoon” aur kai ilzam lagaye gaye, to aap ﷺ ne unko unke lafzon ka jawab nahi diya. Aap ﷺ ka kaam sirf paighaam pohchaana tha — jo Mufti Yasir bhi follow kar rahe hain.

Is Objection Ke Logic Me Kya Kya Ghalatiyan Hain?

Objection Flaws

1. Eye for Eye Fallacy
   Harshness ka jawab harshness se dena Islamic approach nahi — ye tribal revenge mentality hai, Islam nahi.
2. Emotional Immaturity
   Gussa dikhana ya badtameezi karna kisi argument ka jawab nahi hota — ye bas aapki nafsaniyat expose karta hai.
3. False Strength Perception
   Ye samajhna ke “chup rehna kamzori hai” — galat hai. Akhlaaq aur sabr asli taqat hoti hai, jazbaati reaction nahi.
4. Islamic Character Distortion
   Rasool Allah ﷺ ne kabhi gali ka jawab gali se nahi diya. Jo ye karta hai, wo sunnah ke khilaf ja raha hai.
5. Self-Incrimination
   Jo shakhs kisi ko publically “munaafiq” kehta hai bina daleel ke — wo khud apni akhlaaqi haalat ko expose kar raha hota hai.
6. Discussion Sabotage
   Debate ya dialogue me personal attack karna discussion ko khatam kar deta hai. Ye ilm ya logic ka defeat hota hai.

Akhlaaq Se Baat Karna He Asli Taqat Hai – Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts
Muslim hone ka matlab sirf salah ya roza nahi — akhlaaq aur sabr bhi uska bunyadi hissa hai. Gali ka jawab gali se dena humari pehchaan nahi. Jo log sirf provoke karne aaye hote hain, unka jawab silence aur hikmat hota hai. Aaj ke social media ke zamane me jab har koi viral hona chahta hai, sirf wahi viral hona chahiye jisme ilm, akhlaaq aur level ho — nafrat nahi.