OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Religion Practical Ho Sakta Hai?
Bohat se log yeh samajhte hain ke religion ya to sirf emotions ka subject hota hai, ya unrealistic demands se bhara hota hai. Atheist aur secular log aksar yeh objection uthate hain ke religions jaise Christianity, Hinduism, ya Judaism ka system practical nahi hota — ya to sirf rituals hote hain, ya unrealistic ideologies. Unka sawal hota hai: agar Islam bhi ek religion hai, to kya ye bhi utna hi impractical hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Islam Practical Hai Ya Sirf Theoretical?
Islam duniya ka woh system hai jisme har aspect — aqeedah, ibaadat, society, governance — realistic, flexible, aur human nature ke mutabiq hai. Baqi systems ya to temporary needs ke base pe banaye gaye, ya phir insan ki fitrat ko ignore kar ke. Islam har daur ke insaan ke liye naturally practical hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – MUFTI YASIR KA LOGICAL RESPONSE
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke Islam ka har feature — chaahe aqeedah ho, worship ka system ho, ya law ho — human nature ke mutabiq hai:
- Other philosophies jaise Communism ya Liberalism waqt ke reaction ke taur pe aaye. Unka structure ya to collapse ho gaya (e.g. USSR), ya fitrat ke khilaf jaakar society ko tod diya (e.g. family system in Liberalism).
- Religions jaise Christianity ne extreme spirituality ka model diya (rahbaniyat), jo duniya ke liye fit nahi tha. Hinduism ne caste system aur sati jaise rituals diye, jise khud unki community ne reject kiya.
- Islam ne practical aqeedah diya: Na khuda dunya me aata hai, na kisi shakl me. Balki ek insani nabi ko bhejta hai jo humare jaise hota hai — khata hai, peeta hai, bazar jata hai — taake hum follow kar sakein.
- Quran ne aqeedah aur logic ko itne simple andaaz me bayan kiya ke ek aam aadmi bhi relate kar sake. Misal: “Isa aur unki maa khana khate the” – agar khana khana padta hai, to wo khuda kaise ho sakte hain?
OBJECTION FLAWS – Deen Ko Impractical Kehne Wale 5 Ghaltiyan
1. Overgeneralization Fallacy
Sirf kuch religions ke examples lekar saare religions ko impractical keh dena.
2. Human Nature Ignorance
Aise systems design karna jo insan ki zarurat ya instinct ke khilaf ho — jaise liberalism ka anti-family model.
3. Reform Proof Fallacy
Jo deen ya system bar bar reform chahta hai, wo already imperfect tha. Islam kabhi reform nahi hua — because it was already complete.
4. Role Model Disconnect
Khuda ya uske bete ko role model banana impossible hai. Islam me Nabi ﷺ insani level par humare jaise role model hain — real aur relatable.
5. Worship Imbalance
Hindu aur Christian worship ya to caste-based hai ya sirf ritual-based — Islam ne ibadat ko flexible aur universal banaya. Koi bhi, kahin bhi, kisi bhi position me namaz parh sakta hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Practicality Sirf Theory Nahi, Islam Ki Reality Hai
Aaj ke modern zamanay me bhi jab ideologies fail ho rahi hain — Islam aaj bhi zinda hai, amal me hai, aur har level par insani society ke liye applicable hai. Na isme elite bias hai, na caste, na unrealistic goals. Har shakhs ke liye ek hi Allah, ek hi Quran, aur ek hi system — practical, permanent, aur powerful.
