OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Agar Allah ka shape nahi, form nahi… to akhirat me hum use dekhenge kaise?
Atheist aur rationalist log ek common objection uthate hain: “Jiska shape hi nahi, jiska form hi nahi — usse dekha kaise ja sakta hai?”
Unka kehna hai: physical duniya me kuch bhi dekhne ke liye light, direction, distance, aur form ka hona zaroori hota hai. Agar Allah form-less hai, to phir afterlife me dekhna impossible lagta hai.
SHORT ANSWER – Allah ko dekhna duniya ke physics pe nahi, akhirat ke metaphysics pe depend karega
Mufti Yasir kehte hain: ye objection isi liye flawed hai, kyunki hum duniya ke physical rules se akhirat ke metaphysical system ko judge karne ki koshish karte hain.
Allah ko dekhna akhirat ka ek khaas tajurba hoga — jahaan physical conditions (jaise light, form, distance) apply nahi hoti. Allah formless hai, lekin akhirat me dekhna possible hoga kyunki wahan ke rules mukhtalif hain.
DETAILED ANSWER – Duniya ke rules akhirat me nahi chalenge
Duniya me koi cheez dekhne ke liye kuch conditions zaroori hoti hain:
- Object aur eye dono ka exist karna
- Light ka hona
- Ek specific distance
- Direction ya angle
Mufti Yasir ne bataya: agar koi cheez andhere me ho, ya aankh se bahut door ya bahut kareeb ho, to aap use nahi dekh sakte.
Lekin akhirat me hum ek metaphysical dimension me honge — jahan duniya ke physical laws (jaise light aur direction) kaam nahi karte.
Allah formless hai (“Laisa kamislihi shai’un”) — lekin akhirat me usse dekhne ka tajurba possible hai, kyunki wahan ka system totally alag hoga.
Jo log kehte hain: “formless cheez ko kaise dekhenge?” wo asl me duniya ke dimensions se akhirat ko measure kar rahe hain — aur ye hi unka basic flaw hai.
Is concept ko Arabi me kehte hain: “Qiyas al-shahid ‘ala al-ghaib” – yani jo cheez nazar aa rahi hai, uske hisaab se ghaib ko samajhne ki koshish karna.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is logic me 5 major ghaltiyan hain
- 1. False Equivalence: Duniya ke dekhne ke rules akhirat par apply karna scientific nahi — akhirat ek metaphysical reality hai.
- 2. Physical reductionism: Allah ko sirf physical existence ki terms me sochna uski azmat ko kam karna hai.
- 3. Misuse of observation: Har cheez ko dekhna zaroori nahi ke woh form aur shape me ho — akhirat ka experience alag hoga.
- 4. Logical inconsistency: Formless ko na dekh sakne ka matlab ye nahi ke woh exist nahi karta — khudi ke concepts, ideas, aur emotions bhi form-less hain, phir bhi real hain.
- 5. Over-reliance on this-world laws: Physics ki limitations ko akhirat ke logic par apply karna irrational hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Allah ka deedar akhirat ka ek divine gift hai, na ke duniya ka optical experiment
Jo log Allah ko akhirat me dekhne ke concept par hansi udaate hain, wo asal me akhirat ke metaphysical logic ko samajhte hi nahi.
Allah ko dekhna akhirat ke liye reserved ek reward hai — aur duniya ke physical principles is tajurbe ko explain nahi kar sakte.
Yahi to imaan hai — ghaib par yaqeen rakhna, aur akhirat me uska anjaam dekhna.
