OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Islam me sawal karna mana hai?
Ex-Muslims aur kuch non-Muslims ka objection hai ke Islam me sawal karna mana hai. Unka kehna hai ke Quran ne sahaba ko questions puchne se roka tha, aur is wajah se Islam “dogma”-based religion ban gaya jahan blind faith required hota hai. Ye objection kai debates aur online clips me repeat hota hai – lekin iski asal context ko log ignore kar dete hain.
SHORT ANSWER – Islam me sawal mana nahi, unnecessary sawal mana hain
Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke Islam sawal karne ko encourage karta hai – lekin un sawalon ko discourage karta hai jo irrelevant, personal, ya faaltu hoon. Jo sawal deen, reformation, ya aqeedah se related hain, unko Quran aur Sunnah dono support karte hain. Islam ka ilm pochnay se barhta hai – dabaya nahi jata.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: Quran ne sirf faaltu aur irrelevant sawalat se roka
Mufti Yasir ne explain kiya ke Sahaba Rasool ﷺ se har tarah ke sawalat puchte the. Lekin kuch log aise sawal bhi karte the jo na deen se related hote, na insani behtari se – jaise ek sahabi ne pucha: “Mera baap kaun hai?” Jab Rasool ﷺ ne kaha ke aaj jo bhi sawal puchoge jawab milega, to unka lehja thoda serious tha – isliye aise sawal na karne ki hidayat di gayi.
Quran ki ayat: “Do not ask about things which, if made apparent to you, may distress you.” – is ka matlab yeh nahi ke Islam sawal mana karta hai. Balki is ka matlab hai ke aise sawal na karo jo truth open hone par tumhe sharminda kardein, ya jiski koi faida na ho. Deen ke sawalat, aqeedah, ibadat, spirituality – in sab pe poora haq hai pochnay ka.
Dogma ka concept Christianity me tha jahan sawal karna gunah mana jata tha – Islam me nahi. Islam ka ilm logic, Quran, aur reasoning pe based hai – aur Rasool ﷺ ne hamesha ilm hasil karne aur clarity maangne ki hidayat di hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Islam par sawal band karne wale ilzaam ke 5 logical flaws
- Flaw 1: Context Ignorance – Quran ki ayat ka context ignore karke general rule bana diya jata hai.
- Flaw 2: False Equivalence – Islam ko Christian “Dogma” se compare karna galat hai. Islam me questioning allowed hai.
- Flaw 3: Cherry-Picking – Sirf ek waqia uthake Islam ka entire view on questioning ko judge karna unfair hai.
- Flaw 4: Purpose Confusion – Ayah ka maqsad personal sawalon se rokna tha, deen se nahi.
- Flaw 5: Ignoring Prophet’s Method – Rasool ﷺ ne hundreds of deen-based sawalon ke jawab diye, kabhi mana nahi kiya.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Islam ka ilm sawal karne se hi zinda rehta hai
Islam kisi andhi taqleed ya dogma ka system nahi hai. Ye deen aql, daleel aur sawalon ke zariye hi barhta hai. Mufti Yasir ne is debate me sabit kiya ke Rasool ﷺ ka rawayya sawal karne walo ke sath hamesha open aur supportive raha hai – bas un sawalat se roka gaya jo be-maqsad ya personal hoon. Jo log Quran ko science ki tarah read nahi karte, wo context bhool jaate hain – lekin Islam ka message hamesha clear raha hai: “Pucho, samjho, yaqeen hasil karo.”
