Kya Momin Aur Kafir Ko Barabar Treat Karna Chahiye?

Kya Momin Aur Kafir Ko Barabar Treat Karna Chahiye?

Objection Explained
Ek objection yeh uthta hai ke Islam me Allah sab insano ko equal treat nahi karta. Critics kehte hain ke ek momin ka khoon zyada sacred maana gaya hai, jabke ek kafir ka nahi. Unka kehna hai ke agar ek Muslim ne kisi non-Muslim ko qatl kiya, to Muslim to jannat me chala jayega, jabke non-Muslim jahannum me — toh yeh kahan ka insaaf hai?

Kya Momin Aur Kafir Ko Barabar Treat Karna Chahiye? Ka Short Me Jawab

Short Answer
Justice ka matlab yeh nahi ke sabko barabar treat kiya jaye — justice ka matlab hai sabko unke amal ke mutabiq treat kiya jaye. Islam me Allah ka insaaf perfect hai: kafir jahannum me isliye jata hai kyunki usne Allah ko reject kiya, na ke isliye ke wo qatl hua. Aur Muslim agar qatl kare, to usse saza milti hai — agar dunya me mil gayi to akhirat me maafi mil sakti hai, warna wahan bhi poora hisaab hoga.

Kya Momin Aur Kafir Ko Barabar Treat Karna Chahiye? Ka Detailed Jawab

Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne is objection ko logically dismantle kiya. Unhone bataya:

• Quran Surah Nisa (4:93) me kaha gaya hai ke jo shakhs momin ko unki iman ki wajah se qatl kare, uski saza eternal hell hai. Yani yeh Allah ki taraf se sabse sakht warning hai.
• Jahan tak non-Muslim ke qatl ka sawaal hai: agar ek Muslim kisi non-Muslim ko unjustly qatl kare, to us Muslim ka qatl “fasad fil arz” (corruption on earth) ke category me aata hai, jiska anjaam bhi severe punishment hai.
• Jo log yeh kehte hain ke Muslim to baad me tauba karke bach jayega, wo bhool jaate hain ke tauba ka darwaza khula hai lekin guarantee nahi hai — aur Allah ke punishment ka dar bhi sabse bada deterrent hai.
• Islam me do qisam ke huqooq hote hain:
  1. Huquq-ul-Ibad (bandon ke huqooq): inka hisaab akhirat me victim karega, aur wo maaf kare ya na kare, us par depend karega.
  2. Huquq-ullah (Allah ke rights): shirk ko Allah ne clear keh diya hai ke kabhi maaf nahi karega.
• Example diya gaya: secular state bhi rapist aur non-rapist ko equal treat nahi karti — to Allah bhi sabko unke deeds ke basis par judge karega, na ke nominal equality ke basis par.

Kya Momin Aur Kafir Ko Barabar Treat Karna Chahiye? Ka Objection Me Flaws

Objection Flaws

1. Equal ≠ Just
   Justice ka matlab barabari nahi, haqdar ko uska haqq dena hota hai.
2. Death ≠ Hell Entry
   Kisi ka qatl hona uski jannat ya jahannum ka reason nahi — belief aur deeds hi final decision banate hain.
3. Tauba Ka Abuse Misunderstood Hai
   Sirf Muslim hone se tauba ka fayda nahi milta — tauba sincere ho, dunya me saza bhi mile, tabhi Allah ka maghfirah mumkin hai.
4. Punishment Already Exists
   Jo Muslim qatl karta hai, uske liye Islamic law me death penalty, blood money, ya qisaas (equal retaliation) jese options hote hain.
5. Final Judgment Allah Ke Haath Me Hai
   Har shakhs ka decision akhirat me Allah karega — jahan duniya ki niyyatein aur amal dono weigh kiye jayenge.
6. Comparison With Secular Law Is Hypocritical
   Jese secular law me planning-based murder aur accidental killing ka treatment alag hota hai, waise hi Islam bhi context-wise judgment deta hai.

Kya Momin Aur Kafir Ko Barabar Treat Karna Chahiye? Ka Final Jawab

Final Thoughts
Allah ka insaaf sabse perfect hai. Islam sabko unke amal, niyyat, aur aqeede ke basis par treat karta hai. Sirf “equal treatment” ka naara lagana shallow justice hai. Real justice wahi hai jo sab haqooq, sab actions, aur sab intentions ka poora hisaab le. Aur yeh sirf Allah hi kar sakta hai — na secular court, na duniya ka system.