KYA Har Scholar Ki Baat Sunni Chahiye Ya Koi Standard Hona Chahiye?

OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Itne Scholars, Itni Opinions: Kis Par Yaqeen Karein?

Caller ne sawal uthaya ke aaj ke daur me jab har taraf se alag-alag scholars alag baatein karte hain — koi kisi hadith ko reject karta hai, koi tafsir me farq laata hai — to ek aam Muslim kaise decide kare ke konsa scholar sahi hai? Kis ki baat pe chalna chahiye, aur kis se door rehna chahiye?

✅ SHORT ANSWER – Jo scholar Quran, Sunnah, Sahaba aur Salaf ki chain me ho — usi par etemad karein

Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke sahi scholar woh hai jo Rasool ﷺ, Sahaba, Salaf Saliheen aur fuqaha ki chain me ho. Jo Islam ke puraane sanaddar rawayaat ko follow karta ho, na ke naye confusion paida karta ho. Aur agar koi sirf logon ko kafir declare karta phire ya sirf tanqeedi ho — to us se door rehna chahiye.

🔍 DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka method: Pehchaan ka scale kya ho?

Mufti Yasir ne scholar ko pehchaanne ke liye ye 5-point scale diya:

1. Woh Rasool ﷺ par poora iman rakhta ho, unki tauheen na karta ho, unki baat samajhne ki koshish karta ho.
2. Sahaba aur Salaf Saliheen ko haqq ka standard samjhta ho — unki disrespect na karta ho.
3. Uski baat mein narmi ho aur constructiveness ho, sirf negativity aur blame game na ho.
4. Woh confusion paida na karta ho, balki confusion door karta ho.
5. Wo ilm aur akhlaaq dono mein mustahkam ho, na ke sirf YouTube views aur viral clips ke peechay ho.

Aise scholar ki baat agar samajh bhi na aaye, tab bhi wo dangerous nahi hota. Lekin agar koi openly Rasool ﷺ ki baat ko “galat” keh de — to wo Islam se nikal jata hai.

OBJECTION FLAWS – Confusion ka sabab kya hai?

1. Truth ko feelings se naapna
   Jo baat achi lage usi ko follow karna — ye scale nahi. Truth ka scale sanad aur chain of knowledge hoti hai.
2. Too Much Exposure Fallacy
   Har content consume karna bina background ke — confusion paida karta hai. Filtering zaroori hai.
3. Blind Neutrality Myth
   Kehna ke har scholar ko neutral ho kar suno — galat hai. Har scholar sunne ke laayak nahi hota. Kuch sirf taffarqa failate hain.
4. Modern Skepticism Trap
   Sirf un scholars ki sunna jo “bold” ya “rational” dikhte hain — lekin unka aqeeda flawed hota hai.
5. Mixing Waswasa with Real Doubt
   Waswasa (evil thoughts) aur ilm ke shakk me farq hota hai. Dono ko milana confusion barhata hai.

FINAL THOUGHTS – Scholar wahi sahi hai jo deen ko tor’ta nahi, jort’a hai

Aaj har platform pe naye scholars aur “truth-tellers” milte hain. Lekin sahi scholar wohi hota hai jo deen ko jort’a hai, tor’ta nahi. Agar koi Rasool ﷺ, Sahaba, aur salaf ko insult karta hai — uska raasta chor do. Islam koi lab experiment nahi — yeh ek verified chain hai, jisme truth ki security Allah ne rakhi hai. Samajh na aaye to poochho, lekin trust sirf usi par karo jo asli chain me ho.