OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Allah har raat duniya ke aasman par utarta hai?
Ek objector Abu Shakir ne sawaal uthaya: “Agar Allah har raat duniya ke aasman par utarta hai to woh kaise utarta hai?” Unka challenge yeh tha ke koi bhi cheez agar ‘descend’ karti hai to uske physical mechanics hote hain – jaise elevator, jump, ya movement. To kya Allah bhi aise hi utarta hai? Agar nahi, to phir kya ye logic ke khilaaf hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Allah ka nuzool haqiqi hai, magar bighair kaifiyat ke
Mufti Yasir ne jawab diya ke hum Allah ke nuzool par iman rakhte hain, lekin iske tareeqe (kaifiyat) par nahi. Quran aur Hadith me nuzool ka zikr hai, lekin yeh nahi bataya gaya ke kaise hota hai. Jo chiz infinite aur metaphysical hai, uski physical explanation dhoondhna hi logical flaw hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Nuzool ka maana aur logical boundaries of divine action
Abu Shakir ne objection raise kiya ke agar Allah descend karta hai, to kya woh upar se neeche aata hai? Kya uske liye koi jagah chahiye hoti hai? Kya woh earth ke flat model me fit aata hai lekin spherical model me nahi?
Mufti Yasir ne is objection ka philosophical jawab diya:
- Allah ka nuzool haqiqi hai, kyunke Hadith se sabit hai.
- Lekin iska tareeqa unknown hai, aur Quran khud kehta hai: “Laysa kamithlihi shay’” – Us jaisa koi nahi.
- Jab koi sifat (attribute) infinite ho – jaise ilm, qudrat, ya nuzool – to uski exact form explain nahi ki ja sakti.
Yeh aisi hi baat hai jaise koi pooche: Allah ka ilm kitna hai? Ya Allah ki zindagi kis form me hai? Hum kehte hain: wo hai, lekin kaise hai, yeh Allah hi jaanta hai. Isi tarah, nuzool bhi ek sifat hai jiska tariqa insan ke samajh se bahar hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is objection me kya logical faults hain?
- 1. Anthropomorphism Fallacy: Objector ne divine sifat ko human movement ke model me samajhne ki koshish ki.
- 2. False physical assumptions: “Descend” ka matlab sirf physical movement nahi hota, jab wo Allah ke liye use ho.
- 3. Misunderstanding of Islamic metaphysics: Islam divine actions ko kaifiyat ke bagair accept karta hai – ye fundamental aqeeda hai.
- 4. Logical overreach: Jab koi cheez logically unknowable ho, uska na samajhna contradiction nahi hota.
- 5. Ignoring textual clarity: Hadith clearly kehti hai ke Allah nuzool karta hai – iska inkaar nahi kiya ja sakta sirf isliye ke uska mechanism samajh nahi aata.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Har mystery contradiction nahi hoti
Allah ka nuzool ek accepted Islamic belief hai – lekin woh nuzool kaise hota hai, ye na Quran ne bataya, na Hadith ne. Aur jab Allah ne nahi bataya, to hum us par speculation nahi kar sakte. Abu Shakir jese objectors jab logical microscope se metaphysical realities ko judge karne ki koshish karte hain, to wo khud exposed ho jaate hain. Jo baat samajh me nahi aayi, uska inkaar nahi kiya ja sakta. Aqeedah wahi hota hai: “Nuzool hai, magar bighair kaifiyat ke.”
