Kya Murdey Kabristan Me Hamari Baat Sun Sakte Hain?

OBJECTION EXPLAINED – “Quran Me Contradiction Hai: Kabhi Kehta Hai Murde Nahi Sunte, Kabhi Kehta Hai Sunte Hain?”

Ek caller ne confusion uthaya:

• Quran me likha hai “aap murdon ko nahi suna sakte.”
• Lekin dusri jagah yeh bhi aata hai ke “muqarrar salam un tak pahunchta hai.”
  To kya yeh contradiction hai? Kya murde sach me sunte hain ya nahi?

SHORT ANSWER – “Dead Sunte Hain Ya Nahi?” ka Simple Jawab

Murde apni marzi se ya kisi insaan ki koshish se nahi sunte.
Lekin Allah jab chahe, kisi specific baat ko — jaise grave ka salam — un tak pahucha deta hai.
Quran ka yeh kehna ke “aap murdon ko nahi suna sakte” bilkul sahi hai — lekin jab Allah sunwana chahe, to wo sunn lete hain.

DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir Ka Tashreehi Jawab

1. Do Ayatein, Do Maqsad:
   • Surah Fatir me likha hai: “Aap murdon ko nahi suna sakte.”
   • Lekin Hadith aur Qurani themes se maloom hota hai ke Allah jab chahe to salam ko un tak pahucha deta hai.
2. Example:
   • Aap agar kabristan jaake kisi murde ko apni meeting, chai, ya family ka haal sunayen — to wo nahi sunega.
   • Lekin agar aap usay Assalamualaikum ya ahl al-quboor kahkar duaa aur salam deyen, to wo usay Allah ke hukum se sun leta hai.
3. Allah’s Will vs. Human Control:
   • Insan kisi murde ko forcefully sunwa nahi sakta.
   • Magar Allah jab chahe, kisi baat ko us tak direct kar sakta hai.
4. No Contradiction:
   • Ek ayat insani limitation ko clear karti hai.
   • Doosri ayat Allah ki qudrat ko highlight karti hai.

OBJECTION FLAWS – “Murde Nahi Sunte” Argument Me 5 Ghaltiyan

1. Partial Reading of Verses:
Log ayat ka aadha hissa padhte hain aur context nahi samajhte.

2. Human Effort vs. Divine Will ka Confusion:
Quran sirf ye keh raha hai ke insaan murdon ko suna nahi sakta. Ye nahi keh raha ke murde kabhi nahi sunte.

3. Mixing Literal & Spiritual Concepts:
Physical hearing aur ruhani response dono alag cheezen hain.

4. Hadith Ignorance:
Rasool ﷺ ne kabristan me salam dene ka tareeqa bataya — aur kaha ke murde sunte hain.

5. Contradiction Illusion:
Jab Allah ka system samjha jaye, to contradiction khatam ho jata hai.

FINAL THOUGHTS – “Quran Ko Contradict Samajhne Wale Galat Kyu Hain?”

Quran contradiction nahi karta — humari soch incomplete hoti hai.
Jab hum Allah ki qudrat aur apni limit samajh lein, to har confusion clear ho jata hai.
Murda sirf wahi sunta hai jo Allah us tak pahuchata hai — aur yahi aqeedah Quran aur Hadith dono me hai.