OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya secular system Islam se zyada ideal hai?
Aik secular-minded objector ne yeh sawal uthaya ke agar secularism har mazhab ko barabari deta hai, to kya yeh Islamic system se behtar nahi? Usne India aur democratic systems ka zikr karte hue yeh point uthaya ke har religion ko practice ki azadi milti hai, aur is tarah secularism ek fair system hai. Iske muqable me usne Islamic Shari’ah ko theocratic aur freedom-killer system ke roop me present kiya.
SHORT ANSWER – Secularism bhi repress karta hai, sirf style alag hai
Secular system bhi religion ko suppress karta hai — sirf uska andaaz aur justification alag hota hai. Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke secularism ka yeh da’wa ke woh sab religions ko barabar treat karta hai, asal me ek illusion hai. Jab religious practices secular law se takraati hain, to secularism us par restriction laga deta hai — jese 14 saal ki ladki ki marriage, hijab ban, triple talaq, etc.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ne secularism ka contradiction expose kiya
Mufti Yasir ne secularism ke do bare contradictions point out kiye:
1. Belief vs Practice ka farq:
Secular systems kehte hain ke har shakhs kisi bhi cheez ko believe kar sakta hai, lekin jab baat practice ki aati hai, to restrictions lag jati hain. For example, agar koi apne religion ke mutabiq 14 saal ki age me marriage karna chahta hai, to secular system usse rokta hai — lekin agar wahi ladki gender change karna chahe to woh allowed hai.
2. Individual freedom ka illusion:
Secular system me bhi “reasonable restriction” naam ka loophole diya jata hai jiske through kisi bhi religious practice ko ban kiya ja sakta hai. Jaise India me triple talaq ko ban kar diya gaya, hijab par debates hoti hain, aur western nations me Quran rakhna tak crime banaya ja raha hai.
Mufti Yasir ne secularism ko North Korea se compare karte hue kaha ke agar state belief ko allow kare, lekin practice ko punish kare — to phir chahe woh secular ho ya communist, dono ka outcome ek jaisa hai: repression.
Aur sabse critical baat: Mufti Yasir ne yeh point kiya ke secular laws banate kaun hain? Politicians. Aur jab wohi politicians corrupt hon, criminal cases me involve hon, aur unka system propaganda pe chalta ho — to unke banaye qanoon moral authority se bilkul khali ho jate hain.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Islam ya secularism? Asli insaaf ka system kaunsa hai?
Mufti Yasir ne dikhaya ke secularism ek polished control system hai jo freedom ke naam par manipulation karta hai. Islam me law divine hota hai — corrupt politicians ka banaya hua nahi. Secular system me justice ka koi fixed moral base nahi, lekin Islam me insaaf Qurani parameters ke zariye hota hai. Jab tak secular systems ka control corrupt elite ke haath me rahega, insaaf ek illusion hi rahega. Aur isi wajah se Islam, despite propaganda, ek superior aur stable system sabit hota hai.
