Kya Universe Hamesha Se Tha? — Objection Explained
Atheist/Sanatani/Arya Samaji ne sawaal uthaya: “Kya universe eternal hai? Kya duniya kabhi bani hi nahi, ya hamesha se exist karti aa rahi hai? Aur agar sab kuch illusion (jaise dream ya natak) hai, toh Allah ki zarurat hi kya hai?” Aise objections philosophy, science aur Arya Samaji debates me baar baar uthte hain.
Universe Ka Eternal Hona — Short Answer
Short Answer
Mufti Yasir kehte hain: Islam ke hisaab se universe eternal nahi hai — Allah ne isko shuruat di hai, aur ek din khatam bhi kar dega. Science bhi big bang ko universe ki shuruat maanta hai. Jo log kehte hain “duniya hamesha se thi”, unke paas na science ka support hai na logic ka. Reality ka matlab sirf dream nahi — asli reality wahi hai jo insaan ke sochne, mehsoos karne, aur ilm hasil karne se sabit hoti hai.
Universe, Reality aur Science — Detailed Jawab
Detailed Answer
- Islamic View: Quran ke mutabiq, Allah hi Creator hai, universe pehle nahi tha — Allah ne hi create kiya (Surah Anbiya: 30, Surah Hadid: 4).
- Science Ka Point: Modern cosmology (Big Bang Theory) kehta hai universe ki ek definite starting point thi — yani kabhi kuch nahi tha, phir sab kuch bana.
- Arya Samaji/Eternal Universe Claim: Arya Samaji ya kuch philosophers kehte hain universe eternal hai — magar yeh scientific research aur basic logic ke khilaf hai.
- Dream/Natak Theory: Kehna “sab kuch sapna hai, natak hai” — yeh sirf logical escape hai, haqeeqat ko nahi badalta. Agar sab kuch illusion hota, toh ilm, science, discussion, pain, khushi — sab bekaar ho jaate.
- Reality Ka Matlab: Real world wahi hai jo test, logic aur experiment se prove ho sake. Sapna aur haqeeqat alag cheezein hain — aur dono ko differentiate karna insan ki akal ka hissa hai.
Is Objection Ke Logical Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Science Ka Ghalat Use: Science khud kehti hai universe ki shuruat hai, eternal nahi.
- Self-Defeating Logic: Agar sab kuch illusion hai, toh yeh objection, discussion aur thinking bhi illusion ho jate hain — phir kisi bhi baat ki value nahi bachi.
- Contradiction in Eternal Claim: Eternal universe theory na science me support hoti, na logic me — har effect ki koi cause hoti hai, infinite regress possible nahi.
- Philosophical Escape: “Sab kuch sapna hai” kehna asal masail se bhagna hai, logic aur observation ignore karta hai.
- Quranic Argument: Allah ne universe ko shuru kiya, aur wahi khatam bhi karega — isliye creation ka start point logically zaruri hai.
Reality, Illusion Ya Haqeeqat? — Final Thoughts
Final Thoughts
Universe eternal nahi — na science na Islam me. Reality sapna ya illusion nahi, balke woh hai jo insaan test, logic aur experience se jaan sakta hai. Arya Samaji ya atheist logic logical trap hai, asal knowledge, ilm aur soch se bhagna nahi chahiye. Islam insan ko reality face karne, aur logical, ilm par base raasta chune ki dawat deta hai. Soch samajh ke chuno — haqeeqat ya illusion?
