OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Islam kabul karne ke baad kya sare rules turant follow karne hote hain?
Ek ex-Hindu sister ne poocha ke agar wo Islam kabul karein, to kya turant hijab, niqab aur sare Islamic rules par amal karna zaruri hai? Usne ye bhi poocha ke agar Hindu ladka bhi Islam kabul kar le aur dono chhup kar shaadi kar lein, to kya ye theek hoga? Saath hi, usne objection uthaya ke kuch Muslims Hindu festivals me participate karke shirk ko support karte hain – kya ye Islam me allowed hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Islam step-by-step seekhne ka deen hai, lekin shirk se har haal me bachna zaruri hai
Mufti Yasir ne samjhaya ke Islam me har cheez ekdum par lagu nahi hoti — jo cheez kisi ke liye risky ho, usse waqt ke sath implement kiya jata hai. Lekin shirk jaise acts (jaise murti ke saamne jhukna, pooja, ya prasadam lena) kisi surat me jaiz nahi hain. Islam modesty, gradual learning aur survival ko samajhne wala deen hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ne ex-Hindu sister ke har sawaal ka kaise jawab diya?
- Dress Code: Islam me basic principle modesty hai – kapde aise hone chahiye jo body ko expose na karein. Niqab zaruri hai lekin gradually adopt kiya ja sakta hai, especially agar environment hostile ho.
- Shaadi ka Rule: Agar dono Islam kabul kar chuke ho, to simple nikah – 2 gawahon ke samne – valid hai. Hindu rituals (jaise murti puja) haram hain, lekin agar situation risky ho to extreme cases me temporary allowance di ja sakti hai with care.
- Shirk Participation: Mufti Yasir ne saaf kaha ke kisi bhi religious ritual me participate karna, jaise mandir me jhaadu lagana ya prasadam lena, shirk ka support hai — ye Islam me allowed nahi.
- Islam Chhup Kar Rakhna: Agar kisi ko apni jaan ka khatra ho, to Islam chhup kar rakhne ki bhi gunjaish hai. Zaruri nahi ke turant society ya family me elaan kiya jaye.
- Muslims Helping in Hindu Festivals: Mufti Yasir ne distinction diya – general insani madad (jaise COVID me sab ki help) allowed hai, lekin religious rituals (mandir jhaadu, sharbats at puja, etc.) shirk ko promote karte hain — aur ye Islamically ghalat hain.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Ex-Hindu sister ke kuch sawaalon me logic gaps
- Confusion Between Culture & Religion – Har cultural act Islamic nahi hota. Sirf Muslims kar rahe hain to wo Islam ka hissa nahi ban jata.
- Assuming All Muslims Represent Islam – Jo Muslims shirk-supporting kaam kar rahe hain, wo Islam nahi – unki apni galti hai.
- Overgeneralization – NGO ke kuch Muslims agar Hindu rituals me shamil ho rahe hain, to iska matlab pura Islam usko support nahi karta.
- Modesty Misunderstood – Islam me modesty kapdon tak limited nahi hai. Ye gradual transformation ka process hai, na ke sudden change.
- Shirk Ko Nazrana Samajhna – Murti ke liye diya gaya prasadam ya puja ka part koi neutral act nahi — ye shirk ka hissa hota hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Deen ko logon ke actions se nahi, Quran aur Sunnah se samjho
Islam ek rahmat wala deen hai – wo aasan banata hai, mushkil nahi. Jo log usko galat represent kar rahe hain, unse Islam ka asli chehra nahi samjha ja sakta. Agar koi insaan dil se Islam kabul kare, to usse sirf Allah aur Rasool ﷺ ki baat maan kar chalni hai — society ke pressure se nahi. Har naye Muslim ko samajhna chahiye ke Islam gradual steps se bhi accept karta hai, lekin shirk aur clear haram se bachne ka hukm direct aur final hai.
