Kya Burai Ka Badla Burai Se Dena Jaiz Hai?
Objection Explained
Ek caller ne Mufti Yasir se poocha: “Agar kisi ne mere saath burai ki ho to kya main usi level ki burai se badla le sakta hoon?” Caller ne Quran ki ek ayat ka reference diya jisme likha hai ke “burai ka badla usi jaisi burai hai.” Sawal ye tha ke kya ye rule sab logon (maa, baap, bhai-behn) ke liye bhi lagu hota hai?
Kya Burai Ka Badla Burai Se Dena Jaiz Hai?
Short Answer
Quran burai ka badla lene ki ijaazat deta hai — lekin usi ayat me ye bhi likha hai ke maaf kar dena aur islaah karna zyada behtar hai. Apne emotions me insaan aksar overreact karta hai. Isliye Islam ka asal message ye hai: insaaniyat aur akhlaaq ke zariye badla lena nahi, behtari lana.
Kya Burai Ka Badla Burai Se Dena Jaiz Hai?
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne Surah Ash-Shura (42:40) ki ayat ka tazkira kiya:
“Wa jaza’u sayyi’atin sayyi’atun misluha, fa man ‘afa wa aslaha fa ajruhu ‘ala Allah…”
(Iska matlab: Burai ka badla usi jaisi burai hai, lekin jo maaf kare aur islaah kare, uska ajr Allah ke zimme hai.)
- Justice allowed, forgiveness preferred: Quran insaaf ki ijaazat deta hai, lekin agar aap zyada retaliate kar dein to aap bhi zalim ban jaate hain.
- Family ke context me: Maa-baap, bhai-behn ke mamlaat me Islam kabhi bhi burai ke jawab me burai ki encouragement nahi karta. Wahan hamesha husn-e-suluk ki talqeen hoti hai.
- Sila Rehmi ka example: Ek sahabi ne poocha: agar rishte daar mujh par zulm karein to kya mai phir bhi achha sulook karun? Prophet ﷺ ne jawab diya: Sila rehmi ka asal maqam tab hai jab tum achha sulook unse karo jo tumse bura sulook kar rahe ho.
- Emotional reaction is dangerous: Jab insaan ghusse me hota hai, to “barabar ka badla” dena mushkil hota hai — overreaction ke chances zyada hote hain. Isliye Quran maafi aur islaah ko promote karta hai.
Kya Burai Ka Badla Burai Se Dena Jaiz Hai?
Objection Flaws
- Ayat ka aadha hisa lena: Objector ne sirf ayat ka pehla part quote kiya, doosra part (jo maafi aur islaah ki taraf daawat deta hai) ignore kar diya.
- Barabar ka badla mushkil hai: Practically, insaan apne emotions ke control me nahi hota. Overreaction hone ka chance hota hai.
- Family disputes me logic fail hota hai: Maa-baap aur rishte daar ke saath equal retaliation nahi chalta — Quran aur Hadith dono is par husn-e-suluk ka hukum dete hain.
- Quranic tone is descriptive, not prescriptive: Ayat ek universal law explain karti hai — ke duniya me jaise aap karenge, waisa aapke saath hoga. Lekin Islam behtar route recommend karta hai.
- Forgiveness = Greater Reward: Maaf karne wale ke liye Quran me direct ajr ka wada hai — retaliation lene wale ke liye nahi.
- Prophetic Example: Prophet ﷺ ne dushmanon ke zulm par bhi maafi ko prefer kiya — sirf insaaf nahi, akhlaaq bhi diya.
Kya Burai Ka Badla Burai Se Dena Jaiz Hai?
Final Thoughts
Zindagi me sabko bura lagta hai jab unke saath bura sulook hota hai. Lekin asal imtihaan us waqt hota hai jab aap ke paas power hoti hai retaliate karne ki — lekin aap phir bhi maaf karte hain. Mufti Yasir ka paighaam clear hai: Islam aapko revenge ka license nahi deta, aapko akhlaaq ka chance deta hai. Aur asli reward wahi log le jaate hain jo dusre ki burai ko apni bhalaai se jeet lete hain.
