OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Kya Muslim Ko Kabhi Kafir Ke Badle Qatal Kia Jata Hai?
Ek atheist ne debate ke dauraan Sahih Bukhari ki Hadith no. 6915 quote ki, jisme likha hai: “Muslim ko kafir ke badle qatal nahi kiya jayega.” Uska objection ye tha ke agar kisi Muslim ne kisi non-Muslim ko maar diya, to us Muslim ko kyun qatal nahi kiya jata – jabke Islam me ‘qatal ke badle qatal’ ka principle hai? Kya ye justice hai?
SHORT ANSWER – Musalman ne agar Harbi ko mara ho, to us par Qisas q kyun nahi?
Agar koi Muslim kisi enemy combatant ya illegal infiltrator (Harbi) ko qatal kare, to us case me Islamic Qisas (equal retaliation) ka rule lagu nahi hota. Lekin agar woh non-Muslim citizen ho – jaise zimmi ya musta’min – to Muslim par bhi punishment lagu hoti hai. Hukum situation pe depend karta hai.
DETAILED ANSWER – Qatal aur Qisas ka hukum kis par apply hota hai?
Mufti Yasir ne samjhaya ke Hadith no. 6915 me jo kaha gaya ke “Muslim ko kafir ke badle qatal nahi kiya jayega” – ye sabhi kafiron ke liye nahi hai. Ye specific situation ke liye hai: jab ek Muslim kisi Harbi (enemy land ka illegal person) ko qatal karta hai. Harbi wo hota hai jo na zimmi hota hai, na visa leke aata hai – yani ek illegal entrant.
Agar koi non-Muslim zimmi (local tax-paying citizen) ho ya musta’min (visa holder), aur koi Muslim usse qatal kare, to Islamic law me Muslim par bhi qisas hota hai. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ki doosri Hadith bhi hai: “Jo zimmi ko qatal karega, jannat ki khushboo bhi nahi paayega.”
Lekin agar Harbi ko mara gaya hai – yani enemy combatant – to us par Qisas nahi hota, lekin iska matlab ye nahi ke koi bhi Muslim kisi ko bhi maar de. Agar Islamic state chahe, to aise case me bhi tazir (state punishment) apply kar sakti hai. Ye hadith specific situation ke liye thi, aur general rule nahi hai.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is Objection ke 5 Logical Ghalatiyan
- 1. Context Ignorance: Hadith ko context ke bagair quote kiya gaya. Harbi aur zimmi ka farq ignore kiya gaya.
- 2. Generalization Fallacy: Ek specific Hadith ko general rule banake sab Muslim vs non-Muslim cases par apply kar diya.
- 3. Selective Quoting: Prophet Muhammad ﷺ ki doosri Hadiths jahan zimmi ke qatal par punishment mention hai, unko ignore kiya gaya.
- 4. Legal Category Confusion: Islamic law me zimmi, musta’min aur harbi alag categories hain – inka hukum alag hota hai. Ye farq samjha hi nahi gaya.
- 5. Modern Law Parallels Missed: Jese modern laws me illegal entrants par full citizen rights apply nahi hote, Islamic state me bhi Harbi ko zimmi jesa protection nahi milta.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Islam ka Qanoon Zulm nahi, Justice pe Based Hai
Islam kisi ko bhi blanket immunity nahi deta. Har shaks ki legal status pe depend karta hai – chahe Muslim ho ya non-Muslim. Mufti Yasir ne clear kiya ke zimmi ke qatal par Muslim par bhi strict punishment hoti hai. Sirf un cases me qisas apply nahi hota jahan victim illegal combatant ya enemy land ka agent ho. Jo log Islamic justice ko distort karke quote karte hain, wo ya to jante nahi – ya jaan bujh ke mislead karte hain.
