Kya Quran Bible Se Copy Kiya Gaya Hai?
Objection Explained
Ek common objection ye hai ke Quran ne Bible ya dusri purani divine scriptures se stories copy ki hain. Jaise Hazrat Musa (AS), Nooh (AS), Ibrahim (AS) ke waqiyat pehle se Bible me the, to critics kehte hain: “Quran original nahi hai, sirf copy hai.”
Kya Quran Bible Se Copy Kiya Gaya Hai? Ka Short Me Jawab
Short Answer
Quran ne jo waqiyat mention kiye hain, wo wahi asal waqiyat hain jo sabhi divine scriptures me aye the — kyunki source sabka wahi Allah hai. Copy ka ilzam tab banta hai jab source alag ho. Lekin jab Quran aur Bible ka asal source wahi hai, to repetition copy nahi — confirmation hai.
Kya Quran Bible Se Copy Kiya Gaya Hai? Ka Detailed Jawab
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne bataya ke Quran ne Bible se copy nahi kiya, balki unhi asliyat ko dobara reveal kiya jo pehle distort ho chuki thi. Quran kehta hai ke wahi Allah ne Taurat, Zabur, Injil aur akhir me Quran nazil ki — yani source ek hi hai.
Unhone ek logical example diya:
Agar ek author apni pehli 4 books me same waqiyat likhta hai, aur 5th book me bhi wahi likhta hai, to ye “copy” nahi — usi author ka continuity hai.
Waise hi, Quran ne wahi waqiyat dobara bataye, lekin correct form me, distortions ke bagair.
Mufti Yasir ne ye bhi clarify kiya:
- Christians aur objectors khud maan rahe hain ke ye waqiyat pehle se exist karte hain.
- Magar wo ye bhool jaate hain ke Muslims to inhi waqiyat ke source ko same mante hain — to copy ka toh sawaal hi nahi uthta.
- Question ye nahi hona chahiye ke “Quran ne copy kiya?” — balki ye hona chahiye ke kis kitab me asli version preserved hai?
Kya Quran Bible Se Copy Kiya Gaya Hai? Ka Objection Me Flaws
Objection Flaws
- Same Source Ignore Karna
Jab Muslims aur Christians dono prophets ko maante hain, aur wahi source Allah hai — to copy ka concept hi ghalat hai. - Plagiarism vs. Revelation Confusion
Copy tab hoti hai jab author alag ho. Yahaan wahi same Allah ne alag zamano me wahi bheji. - Distorted Scriptures Ko Benchmark Banana
Bible aur dusri kitaabein distort ho chuki hain — Quran ne asli waqiyat ko restore kiya. - Confirmation Ko Copy Kehna
Quran ne kai jagah khud kaha: “Ye wahi baat hai jo pehle bhi nazil ki gayi thi.” Ye copy nahi, tasdeeq hai. - Logical Example Ko Ignore Karna
Ek author apne hi content ko repeat kare to wo copy nahi hota — waise hi Quran Allah ka final and pure message hai.
Kya Quran Bible Se Copy Kiya Gaya Hai? Ka Final Jawab
Final Thoughts
Copy ka ilzam tabhi lagta hai jab intention deception ho — lekin Quran openly kehta hai ke ye wahi waqiyat hain jo pehle bhi aayi thi. Farq ye hai ke dusri kitaabein distort ho gayi, aur Quran wahi asliyat lekar aya jise Allah ne protect kiya. Sochne ka sawaal ye nahi ke kisne copy kiya — balki ye ke kis ne sach ko preserve kiya.
