Kya Liberal Soch Waqai Azadi Deti Hai?
Liberalism vs Islam Ka Asli Masla Kya Hai?
Objection Explained
Ek Hindu liberal ne debate mein yeh dawa kiya ke woh “liberated” hai jabke Muslims ek codified belief system ke “gulam” hain. Usne Islamic modesty (burqa, ghunghat) ka mazaaq banaya, Quran par slavery promote karne ka ilzam lagaya aur Muslim invaders par aurton ko gulam banane ka charge bhi lagaya. Mufti Yasir ne is objection ka har pehlu se jawab diya — logical, theological aur historical.
Is Liberal Soch Ka Koi Seedha Jawab Hai?
Short Answer
Jo khud apne society, culture aur religion se sharminda ho kar West ki values ko copy kare, woh liberate nahi — enslaved hota hai. Islam ne slavery ko promote nahi kiya, balki systematically end kiya. Aur burqa ya modesty ko backward kehna ek biased Western lens ka natija hai.
Mufti Yasir Ka Detailed Analysis
Detailed Answer
Mufti Yasir ne sabse pehle yeh bataya ke Quran ka mission “gulamon ko azad karna” hai — Surah Al-Balad ki ayat “Fakku raqabah” iska saboot hai. Islami system mein agar slavery thi bhi to woh war-based system ka hissa thi, jo us waqt har civilization mein common tha. Quran ne hamesha slaves ko free karne, unke saath insaniyat aur izzat se pesh aane ka hukm diya.
Phir unhone Hindu society ke devadasi system ka zikr kiya — jahan mandiron mein ladkiyon ko enslaved kiya jata tha sexual service ke liye. Kya us practice ko liberalism kehna chahiye? Hindu history mein caste-based slavery aur stree-par-adhikar ke kitne examples hain — lekin unhe disown nahi kiya jata.
Jo shakhs liberalism ke naam par Muslim auraton ki modesty ko target karta hai, woh asal mein West ki values ka ghulam hai. Jab Mufti Yasir ne pucha ke kya tum apni maa-behen ko bikini mein road par dekhna pasand karoge, to saamne wale ne ghooma phira diya. Kyun? Kyunke woh bhi apne andar se West ki extreme nudity ko accept nahi kar pa raha tha.
Objection Mein Kya Logical Flaws Hain?
Objection Flaws
- Selective outrage: Islamic modesty ko criticize karna, lekin Hindu devadasi ya ghunghat culture se anjaan rehna.
- False equivalence: Quran mein “slave” word ka hona = slavery promote karna? Galat.
- Historical ignorance: Muslim invasions ke naam par sabko culprit banana, bina evidence ke.
- Contradiction: Khud liberal values ke against hota hai jab apne ghar ki aurat ki baat aati hai.
- Moral double standard: Bikini ko liberalism ka standard banana, lekin use real life mein accept na kar pana.
- Fake liberation: Jo West ke norms follow kare, woh liberated nahi — confused hai.
- Misuse of terminology: “Codified belief = slavery”? Toh phir Constitution bhi slavery hona chahiye!
Aakhir Mein Kya Samajhna Zaroori Hai?
Final Thoughts
Islam ki guidance insan ko khuli hawa mein le jaati hai, jahan fitrat aur logic dono ka izzat hoti hai. Jo log liberalism ke naam par apne mazhab, culture aur values se sharminda hain — woh asal mein enslaved hain. Mufti Yasir ne point-by-point ye saabit kiya ke Islam ne na sirf slaves ko azadi di, balki soch ko bhi azaad kiya. Aur jo shakhs apne andar ki contradictions se anjaan ho, uska “liberated” hona sirf ek illusion hai.
