OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Non-Muslim ne Musalman ki jaan bachayi, to kya usay bhi Jannat milegi?
Ek objector ne sawal uthaya: Turkey ke earthquake ke baad kuch Indian army ke non-Muslim soldiers ne wahan jakar Musalmano ki jaan bachayi. Kya Allah itne dayalu nahi ke aise noble kaam karne wale non-Muslim ko bhi Jannat de de? Uska kehna tha ke agar koi insaan kisi Musalman ki madad karta hai, to sirf isliye use Hell me bhejna na-insafi hogi.
SHORT ANSWER – JANNAT SIRF ALLAH KI ITAAT SE MILTI HAI, MADAD SE NAHI
Acha amal (like kisi ki jaan bachana) zarur valuable hai, lekin Jannat ka darwaza sirf un logon ke liye khulta hai jo Allah ki authority ko tasleem karte hain. Agar koi banda Allah ko maane bina sirf madad kare, to uske ache amal ka reward duniya me ho sakta hai – akhirat me nahi.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ka jawab: Authority ke baghair reward nahi milta
Mufti Yasir ne is objection ka jawab ek practical misaal se diya:
Agar ek Indian soldier apni sarkar ke hukum ke khilaf kisi dusri country me madad karne jaye, to chahe usne kitna bhi acha kaam kiya ho, usne apni authority ko challenge kiya – aur isi wajah se use punishment mil sakti hai.
Isi tarah, agar koi insan Allah ki zameen me rehkar usi Allah ko na maane, lekin achhe kaam karta rahe, to woh core compliance tod raha hota hai. Islam ke mutabiq, Allah ne hidayat ka ek system banaya hai – usay follow karne wale ko reward milta hai, aur us system ko reject karne wale ko nahi.
Jese corporate company me koi employee acha kaam kare lekin policy tod de, to use nikaala ja sakta hai – waise hi Allah ki policy me shirk aur kufr sabse bara breach hai. Acha amal karne ke bawajood, agar insan Allah ki authority ko reject karta hai, to akhirat ka reward nahi milta.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Is objection me 5 logical problems
1. Emotional Appeal Fallacy:
Objector ne sirf emotional base par judge kiya – logic ya divine law ke perspective se nahi.
2. Outcome Bias:
Jaan bachana ka result acha hai, lekin us action ki niyyat aur belief system ka bhi role hota hai. Islam me akhirat ka reward niyyat aur imaan dono par depend karta hai.
3. Authority Denial:
Acha kaam tabhi fully valid hota hai jab wo authority ke rules ke andar ho. Allah ki authority ko reject karna sabse bada issue hai.
4. Conditional Goodness Misunderstood:
Objector ne samjha ke acha kaam karne wale ko automatically Jannat milni chahiye. Lekin Islam me imaan bina amal adhoora hai, aur amal bina imaan be-asar.
5. Islamic Principle ko Christian Culture se compare karna:
Objector ne indirectly Christian concepts jaise “just be good” ko Islam ke “submit to God” se compare kiya, jabke dono ka reward system alag hai.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Jannat ek reward hai, free pass nahi
Islam me Jannat milti hai Allah ki authority ko tasleem karne ke baad. Acha amal uske baad reward ko barhata hai, lekin uska gateway imaan hai. Agar imaan nahi, to achhai ka bhi scale sirf duniya tak hota hai – akhirat tak nahi. Ye rule harsh nahi, balki consistent hai. Jaise company me compliance breach pe termination hota hai, waise hi shirk aur kufr par akhirat me accountability hoti hai.
