OBJECTION EXPLAINED – Mango Quran me kyu mention nahi hai?
Ek objector ne sawal uthaya ke agar Quran sab kuch explain karta hai, to mango jaise fruits ka zikr kyun nahi hai? Uska kehna tha ke sirf dates (khajoor) ka zikr milta hai, lekin aam (mango) jaisa fruit — jo India-Pakistan me common hai — uska Quran me koi hawala nahi. Is objection ke zariye woh Quran ke universality par sawal uthana chahta tha.
SHORT ANSWER – Quran ka maqsad fruit list dena nahi, message dena hai
Quran ka objective fruit list banana nahi, balki universal hidaayat dena hai. Khajoor ka zikr us culture ke hawale se hai jahan Quran nazil hua, lekin Arabic grammar me ‘Alif Laam Jinsi’ ka use yeh dikhata hai ke Quran har tarah ke fruits ko include karta hai — chahe woh mango ho ya melon.
DETAILED ANSWER – Mufti Yasir ne Arabic grammar ka concept samjhaya
Mufti Yasir ne explain kiya ke jab Quran me “As-Samawat” (heavens), “Ash-Shams” (sun), “Al-Qamar” (moon) ya “An-Nakhl” (dates) ka zikr hota hai, to yeh singular items nahi balki ek category ka zikr hota hai. Arabic language me jab “Al” (Alif Laam) ka istimaal hota hai to wo Alif Laam Jinsi hota hai — matlab, poori category ko cover karta hai.
Jaise “Al-Insaan” (insaan) ka matlab hota hai har insaan, chahe white ho ya black, eastern ho ya western. Isi tarah, agar Quran me “fruit” ya “trees” ka zikr hai to wo mango ko bhi include karta hai — bhale naam se na ho.
Mufti Yasir ne yeh bhi kaha ke agar Quran har mulk ke local fruits ko list karne lage to uska message universal nahi, regional ban jata. Quran ne local example diya (jaise khajoor), lekin uska maqsood sirf ek fruit nahi, balki ek poori category ko samjhana tha.
OBJECTION FLAWS – Yeh sawal logic ke kitne flaws show karta hai?
1. Category ko individual samajhna
Quran me “Alif Laam” ka istemal poori category ke liye hota hai — ek fruit mention karna matlab sab ko include karna.
2. Regional bias ka apply karna
Aam India ka local fruit hai. Agar har region ka fruit likha jaye to Quran encyclopedia ban jata — guidance nahi.
3. Language ignorance
Objector ne Arabic grammar ka base hi ignore kiya — Quran Arabic me hai, to uski structure ko samajhna zaroori hai.
4. Literalism over message
Quran metaphor aur language devices use karta hai. Literal list lena Quran ka misuse hai.
5. Wrong comparison with mythology
Quran ek divine message hai, not a storybook. Isme practical guidance aur symbolic references hote hain, na ke detailed inventories.
FINAL THOUGHTS – Quran ka message fruit ke naamon se zyada gehra hai
Quran ka maksad logon ko hidaayat dena hai, na ke seasonal fruits ki list banana. Agar kisi word ka naam nahi bhi aaya, to uska matlab yeh nahi ke woh Quran ke message me shaamil nahi hai. Arabic grammar me har word ke peeche ek hikmat hoti hai — aur Mufti Yasir ne yeh sabit kiya ke mango jaisa fruit Quran ke universal structure me already shaamil hai, bas Arabic ko samajhne ki zarurat hai.
